Facilitator Manual
Small Business Edition
A Framework for Understanding and
Implementing an Entrepreneurial Mindset
ICE HOUSE
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
PROGRAM
Who Owns the Ice House
@IceHouseEP #WOIH
NONRETURNABLE
IF SHRINK WRAP BROKEN
3
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
Copyright © 2015 by the Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC.
All rights reserved.
First Edition: February 2015
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced,
stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by
any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or
otherwise, without written permission of the publisher.
This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative
information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold with
the understanding that the publisher and authors are not engaged
in rendering legal, accounting, or other professional services. If
legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of
a competent professional should be sought.
Publisher
Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC
Director of Content Development
Gary Schoeniger
Senior Content Project Manager
Sam Kruse
Layout and Art Designer
Guillaume Muller-Greven
Content Contributors
Michael Crawford, Joanie Weber
Executive Editor
Sam Kruse
Developmental Editor
Joanie Weber
4
5
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
Optional Course Elements 41
Companion Text 41
Reflection Assignments 41
THE ICE HOUSE METHODOLOGY 43
Peer to Peer Learning 43
Community Engagement 44
Sample Delivery Schedule 47
3-session Boot Camp 47
6-week Blended Delivery 52
COURSE ASSIGNMENTS 57
Optional Assignments and Course Materials 78
Facilitator Generated Discussion Questions 78
Reflection Assignments 84
Presentation Assignments 85
True/False Checkpoints 87
Recommended Supplemental Resources 96
TABLE OF CONTENTS
COURSE OVERVIEW 8
Introduction 8
Welcome 8
Defining Entrepreneurship 8
What Is a Mindset? 9
Facilitator’s Role 9
The Ice House Entrepreneurs 10
Course Outcomes and Learning Objectives 12
How It Works: Brief Overview 13
Primary Course Elements 13
Additional Course Elements 13
Lesson Overviews 14
COURSE ELEMENTS AND FACILITATION 17
Chalkboard Lessons 17
Abbreviated Chalkboard Lessons 17
In-Class Discussions 19
Peer Workshop 19
Chalkboard Discussions 22
Application Assignments 23
The Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas 25
Back of Canvas Analysis 26
When Does the Opportunity Discovery Process End? 26
Canvas in Action 29
Phase 1: Understanding the Problem 29
Phase 2: Finding a Solution 32
Phase 3: Problem-Solution-Connection 36
6
7
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
8
9
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
COURSE OVERVIEW
INTRODUCTION
Welcome
The Ice House Entrepreneurship Program™ is an experiential problem-based learning
program designed to inspire, inform and involve participants in the fundamental aspects of an
entrepreneurial mindset and the unlimited opportunities it can provide. Designed for rigor and
relevance, the program provides a comprehensive framework for understanding and implementing
an entrepreneurial mindset, regardless of one’s chosen path.
The Facilitator Manual is designed to help you and your participants get the most out of their
entrepreneurial learning experience. Please remember, this is a guide. As a facilitator, you bring
valuable knowledge and experience to the classroom and you know your participants best. We
encourage you to adjust the guidelines and delivery schedule as needed for your particular
audience.
Defining Entrepreneurship
Entrepreneurship can empower ordinary people to accomplish extraordinary things. In today’s
world, it is a skill that every participant needs, regardless of their chosen path. Yet, the
entrepreneurial process is still not well understood and therefore not easy to define.
Here we will simply define entrepreneurship as the Opportunity Discovery Process. It is a
search process whereby the participant is encouraged to identify and solve problems in real-
world, ambiguous and resource-constrained circumstances; this is a process that will develop
entrepreneurial skills.
The Opportunity Discovery Process is an iterative, experimental process that can empower anyone
to succeed. It does not require the invention of new technologies or a computer science degree. It
does not require years of industry experience, in-depth planning and market research. Nor does it
require access to venture capital investors or an Ivy League MBA.
Entrepreneurship is a discovery process that requires interaction, observation, experimentation and
adaptation. It is a participant-centric process that requires curiosity and creativity, critical thinking
and effective problem solving, communication, collaboration and teamwork - skills that anyone can
apply.
What is a Mindset?
A mindset is a mental model - a deeply ingrained set of beliefs and assumptions that influence our
decisions and our behavior. Very often we are not aware of our mindset and the effect it has on the
decisions we make and ultimately, the outcome of our lives.
And, when it comes to entrepreneurship, there is no proven formula that will guarantee success,
yet there is a fundamental logic - a mindset - that guides the decisions that enable entrepreneurs to
succeed. For the purpose of this program, we will define the term “entrepreneurial mindset” as the
underlying beliefs and assumptions that drive the behavior that enables entrepreneurs to succeed.
At the core of an entrepreneurial mindset is the ability to discover problem-solving opportunities
without special talents, access to abundant venture capital or creating breakthrough technology.
This mindset ignites the process of searching for the intersection of one’s interests and abilities with
the needs of our fellow human-beings. It is a mindset cultivated through an experimental process
that requires curiosity, creativity, critical thinking and communication.
It is also important to remember that not everyone needs to start a business to benefit from an
entrepreneurial mindset. Entrepreneurs come in all shapes and sizes, and entrepreneurial thinking
can be applied to a variety of circumstances from non-profit and social ventures to workforce
development and educational success.
Facilitator’s Role
The course is designed as a participant-centered, problem-based learning program whereby the
teacher assumes the role of facilitator rather than a subject matter expert.
After all, entrepreneurship is a discovery process that requires the participant to take ownership
of their ideas, as well as their ability to learn. Problems can be solved in many different ways and
have more than one possible solution. Your role as facilitator is to create and maintain a safe and
challenging learning environment designed to encourage self-directed learning, critical thinking,
effective problem solving and other entrepreneurial skills.
The facilitator helps participants draw on their existing knowledge and then facilitates access
to knowledge where gaps are identified and accepted. Facilitators help participants cope with
uncertainty, provide encouragement and support, point out difficult issues, encourage involvement,
push for action and manage time.
10
11
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
The Ice House Entrepreneurs
The Ice House Entrepreneurs were carefully selected from a wide range of backgrounds and
interests. Most started with little or nothing. Similar to Clifton’s Uncle Cleve, they all faced hardship
and adversity on the road to success. Yet they were each willing to share their knowledge and
experience as a way to inspire and encourage others to embrace entrepreneurship as a way of life.
Their stories are remarkable. The lessons they provide can be life changing.
Dawn Halfaker: As a severely disabled veteran, Capt. (Ret.) Dawn Halfaker never
thought of herself as an entrepreneur. Yet, after losing her right arm while serving in Iraq,
she found herself faced with challenges that ultimately empowered her to succeed. Today,
she is the founder and CEO of Halfaker & Associates, a global consulting firm with more
than 150 employees.
David Petite: As a Native American raised by a single mother, inventor and entrepreneur
David Petite soon became enlightened in the ways of becoming self-sufficient. After failing
at his first business, he learned a valuable lesson that ultimately enabled him to succeed.
Today, he is one of America’s most prolific inventors who holds more than 50 patents
worldwide.
Brian Scudamore: Starting with little more than $700 and a few fliers, Brian Scudamore
transformed a simple idea into a very successful business. Today, his company 1-800
GOT JUNK has grown to annual sales in excess of $100 million with more than 300
locations throughout Canada, Australia and the US.
Ryan Blair: Ryan Blair knows about building a business from the ground up. Like many
entrepreneurs he had no formal business education. “I was a punk with a juvenile criminal
record and a lot of emotional scarring,” Blair explained. Yet a chance encounter with
a successful entrepreneur shifted his perspective and enabled him to become a very
successful serial entrepreneur.
Lydia Gutierrez: Growing up in inner-city Detroit, Lydia Gutierrez and her late husband
Richard started what would become a multi-million dollar business with little more than a
few hundred dollars and a simple idea. Today, her company Hacienda Foods is one of
Detroit’s fastest growing companies with more than 80 employees and nearly $10 million
in annual sales.
Rodney Walker: Growing up as a foster child on the south side of Chicago, Rodney Walker
could not imagine a life beyond the dismal circumstances that surrounded him. Yet an
entrepreneurial experience in high school shifted his perspective and, with the help of a mentor,
he has become a scholar who attended Morehouse College and completed graduate studies at
Yale.
Palwasha Siddiqi: As a young woman born in Afghanistan, Palwasha faced unimaginable
obstacles in her journey to becoming an entrepreneur. After fleeing her war-torn home,
she spent years in a refugee camp where she encountered an American entrepreneur.
Inspired, she became determined to overcome the social, cultural and economic barriers to
become an entrepreneur.
Jason Campbell: At the age of 16, Jason Campbell was a foster child who had dropped
out of school. Yet an entrepreneurial experience shifted his perspective and, with the
help of a mentor, he re-enrolled in school. Today, he is a decorated combat veteran
and successful participant with a degree in foreign relations from San Francisco State
University.
Scott Saunders: After graduating from Columbia University with a MBA, Scott Saunders
found himself in an unfulfilling career. Using his financial skills he saw an opportunity to
help others. Today, he is the founder and CEO of Payoff.com, an online tool that helps
people manage their money, reduce their debts and fund their dreams.
Carey Mobius: At the age of 18, Carey Mobius suddenly found himself in charge of a failing
family business. With $275 in the bank and $275,000 in debt, Carey asked himself an important
question: “How do you succeed when you start with less than nothing and you know nothing?”
Today, his company Garibaldi Glass has become a global leader in his field.
Susana Cabrera: As an immigrant entrepreneur, Susana Cabrera faced enormous obstacles
on her journey to succeed. Through perseverance and determination, she managed to transform
her Latin American food products into Delicious Bites, a nationally recognized brand offered in
more than 700 grocery stores nationwide.
Dr. Fitz Hill: As an entrepreneur, Dr. Fitz Hill knew that problems were often opportunities in
disguise. Combining his skills as a football coach with those he learned as an entrepreneur, he
transformed Arkansas Baptist College into a nationally recognized pillar of higher education and
a thriving entrepreneurial community.
Keith Kokal: Growing up in inner city Cleveland, Keith Kokal quickly learned how to survive.
From shoe shining to auto repair, he soon learned that solving problems for other people would
enable him to succeed. Today, his company Micro Laboratories is a widely respected world
leader in precision calibration services.
Ted and Sirena Moore: As a single teenage mother, Sirena refused to drop out of school.
Together with her father Ted, they managed to transform a few hundred dollars and a
simple idea into a sustainable success. Today, their company Elohim Cleaning Contractors
employs more than 50 people as they continue to learn and grow.
12
13
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
COURSE OUTCOMES & LEARNING OBJECTIVES
How do entrepreneurs identify opportunities that others overlook? How are they able to transform
a simple idea into a sustainable success? What are the underlying beliefs and assumptions that
drive the behavior that enables them to succeed, regardless of where they begin? These are the
overarching questions that the Ice House Entrepreneurship Program seeks to answer. These
questions should be revisited frequently throughout the learning experience.
From a small business development perspective, the program is designed to develop an
entrepreneurial mindset, which includes the following skills:
Opportunity Identification: Participants learn to recognize problems or needs whose potential
solutions align with their own unique knowledge, skills, interests, and experience. Participants
will initiate market opportunities by connecting real-world problems with market-based solutions,
all while learning how to utilize the bootstrapping method to establish a client-funded business.
Idea Validation: Using an iterative approach to learning, participants implement the Opportunity
Discovery Canvas to evaluate new market opportunities and reduce unnecessary risk.
Participants continuously improve their business ideas and progress towards a problem-solution
fit through regular reflection and critical feedback from program peers and potential customers.
Analysis and Planning: Participants develop their ability to learn “on-the-fly,” quickly analyzing
the outcomes of interactions with customers and stakeholders, and planning next steps to
advance through the entrepreneurial process. Instead of reacting to unforeseen circumstances
or results, participants learn to respond intentionally, calibrating their decisions based on past
experience, present context, and future goals.
Reflection: Participants develop their ability to learn “on-the-fly,” quickly analyzing the outcomes
of interactions with customers and stakeholders, and planning next steps to advance through
the entrepreneurial process. Instead of reacting to unforeseen circumstances or results,
participants learn to respond intentionally, calibrating their decisions based on past experience,
present context, and future goals.
Branding: Participants learn to establish a personal brand and reputation that can drive the
growth and sustainability of their business ideas. Through applied practice of face-to-face
interviews, business pitches, and written assignments, participants develop the ability to
communicate their mission to fit the needs of the market
Professional Networking: Participants bolster their professional networks and their networking
savvy through frequent peer interaction and engagement with local entrepreneurs and
community leaders. The out-of-the-building approach to entrepreneurship enables participants to
connect with customers and stakeholders who share an interest in solving market problems and
who can help participants grow their business ideas.
Lifelong Learning: The Ice House Opportunity Discovery Process emphasizes the importance
of continuous learning from and through both formal and informal knowledge sources and
processes. Participants develop a strategic approach to succeed in their business endeavors
by applying knowledge and skills acquired from the course content and during the Opportunity
Discovery Process.
HOW IT WORKS: A BRIEF OVERVIEW
Primary Course Elements
Video Chalkboard Lessons: Narrated online lectures that combine basic bullet-point text,
graphic animation, and brief video interview segments with successful entrepreneurs. True/False
questions are embedded throughout the lessons as ungraded “checkpoints” between individual
chapters.
Peer Workshops: Opportunities to reflect and assess the progress of their business ideas
by discussing with their peers their experiences with the Opportunity Discovery Process. Peer
Workshops also allow participants to conduct “pitch” presentations and to learn from guest
lectures.
Application Assignments: Real-world entrepreneurial experiences that enable participants to
engage in entrepreneurial seeing, thinking, and behaving, while developing entrepreneurial skills.
Following the Ice House Opportunity Discovery Process, participants learn to identify, evaluate,
and develop new opportunities through an iterative experimental approach.
Optional Course Elements
Companion Text: Who Owns the Ice House? - Eight Life Lessons from an Unlikely
Entrepreneur by Pulitzer nominee Clifton Taulbert and Gary Schoeniger. The book serves to
reinforce the key concepts while demonstrating the power of an entrepreneurial mindset as a
means of self-reliance and empowerment.
Chalkboard Discussions: In-class discussions of the chalkboard lessons are a supplemental
opportunity for participants to broaden and deepen their understanding of key concepts.
Chalkboard discussions provide a forum for participants to compare and contrast Ice House
14
15
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
concepts with their own experiences and prior knowledge.
Reflection Assignments: Provide an opportunity for participants to think and write reflectively
about the future they want to create and how they can apply the knowledge and skills they
have acquired throughout the course. Primarily, the Personal Vision Statement should include
a road map for how participants intend to apply the core concepts to overcome obstacles and
accomplish their goals.
LESSON OVERVIEWS
Below is a description of each chalkboard lesson and the individual chapters contained within each
lesson. The diagram below provides a brief overview of the eight core concepts.
Introduction: The introductory lesson offers a brief overview of the eight life lessons, an
introduction to several of the Ice House Entrepreneurs, as well as a look beneath the surface
to examine some of the most commonly held myths about what it really takes to succeed as an
entrepreneur. We’ll also introduce some basic concepts about entrepreneurship that are essential
to understand.
Lesson 1 - The Power to Choose: Life is not a lottery. The ability to choose the way we respond
to our circumstances is fundamental to an entrepreneurial mindset. In Lesson 1, participants
will understand the importance of an internal versus an external locus of control and how each
perspective can influence critical decisions.
Lesson 2 - Recognizing Opportunities: Problems are often opportunities in disguise.
Entrepreneurs are problem solvers, and the secret to their success lies in their ability to
identify and solve problems regardless of what they have to work with or where they start.
In Lesson 2, participants will learn how entrepreneurs identify and evaluate opportunities through a
process of interaction and observation, experimentation and adaptation.
Lesson 3 - Ideas into Action: Think big. Start small. Act fast. Entrepreneurs are action oriented,
and they tend to focus their time and energy on things they can change rather than things they
cannot. In Lesson 3, participants will learn how to start where they are, overcome inertia, and test
their ideas in real-world circumstances.
Lesson 4 - Pursuit of Knowledge: Our effort can only take us as far as our understanding.
Entrepreneurs are self-directed, lifelong learners who understand the power of knowledge
combined with effort. In Lesson 4, participants will learn how to find the knowledge they need in
order to accomplish their goals.
Lesson 5 - Creating Wealth: Spending or investing? For most, it’s not the lack of money that
prevents us from prospering. In Lesson 5, participants will learn basic financial literacy from an
entrepreneurial perspective. Participants will also learn how entrepreneurs leverage their resources
to accomplish their goals.
Lesson 6 - Building Your Brand: Actions speak louder than words. Entrepreneurs are problem
solvers, and reliability is the key to their success. In Lesson 6, participants will learn how to build a
brand -- from finding the first customers to building a lasting reputation that leads to sustainability
and growth.
Lesson 7 - Creating Community: Entrepreneurs understand the power of positive influence, and
they learn to surround themselves with others who have been where they intend to go. In Lesson 7,
participants will understand the importance of experienced entrepreneurs as mentors and advisors
who can provide critical guidance and support.
Lesson 8 - The Power of Persistence: Entrepreneurship is not “get rich quick,” and expecting
it to be easy is a mistake. The “secret” behind every entrepreneur’s success is hard work,
perseverance, and determination. Lesson 8 provides an inside look at the power of persistence and
how the Ice House Entrepreneurs used adversity as an advantage to help them accomplish their
goals.
17
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
COURSE ELEMENTS AND FACILITATION
CHALKBOARD LESSONS
Chalkboard Lessons create the core of the Ice House Entrepreneurship Program. The narrated
chalkboard lectures combine basic bullet-point text and graphic illustrations with brief video
segments featuring case studies of successful everyday entrepreneurs. Selected from a wide variety
of backgrounds and interests, the Ice House Entrepreneurs offer powerful insights and real-life
experiences that help reinforce the key concepts contained within each lesson.
The Chalkboard Lessons range from approximately 35-75 minutes in length. Each Chalkboard
Lesson is divided into brief video chapters that range from 3-10 minutes in length. True/False
questions are randomly embedded as ungraded “checkpoints” between individual chapters that
participants complete before proceeding to the next chapter.
ABBREVIATED CHALKBOARD LESSONS
Facilitators that implement the Ice House Entrepreneurship Program using an abbreviated delivery
schedule (such as a weekend boot camp format or a 4-6 week short course format) may choose
to shorten the assignment lengths by only requiring participants to view selected clips from each
Chalkboard Lesson. The following section outlines recommendations for shortened versions of each
Chalkboard Lesson, only including the most essential video chapters from each lesson. Regardless
of delivery schedule, facilitators and participants will still have access to the complete series of
Chalkboard Content.
Introduction
(Full Video: 35:40)
Introduction 2:27-4:10 (1:43)
CH 1 4:10-5:59 (1:49)
CH 3 20:42-26:02 (5:20)
CH 4 26:02-34:38 (8:36)
___________________________________
Total Time (17:28 )
___________________________________
Lesson 1: The Power to Choose
(Full Video: 47:21)
CH 2: 17:33-25:58 (8:25)
CH 3: 25:58-32:54 (6:56)
___________________________________
Total Time (15:21)
___________________________________
18
19
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lesson 6: Building Your Brand
(Full Video: 56:26)
CH 2: 14:05-25:49 (11:44)
CH 3: 0:00-6:43 (6:43)
____________________________________
Total Time (18:27)
____________________________________
Lesson 8: The Power of Persistence
(Full Video: 102:25)
IN-CLASS DISCUSSIONS
In-class discussions are crucial to the successful delivery of the Ice House Entrepreneurship
Program. Peer Workshops are the primary method of in-class discussion, allowing participants to
share and explore real-world experiences with the Opportunity Discovery Process. As a supplement
to Peer Workshops, Chalkboard Discussions are the secondary type of in-class discussion, enabling
participants to delve deeper into course content and lesson-specific concepts.
Peer Workshops
Peer Workshops are critical to the effective implementation of the Ice House Entrepreneurship
Program. Utilizing a flipped-classroom model, Peer Workshops provide a forum for participants
to share experiences with the Opportunity Discovery Process, conduct pitch presentations, and
provide peer-to-peer feedback. Peer workshops also provide an opportunity for local entrepreneurs
to present guest lectures as well as provide key guidance and support.
Peer Workshop Presentations
Presentations allow participants to share what they are learning in a formal setting,
providing an opportunity to develop oral presentation and communication skills by
“pitching” their ideas and conveying the evolution of their Opportunity Discovery Process.
Presentations also provide an opportunity for participants to respond to questions and
peer-to-peer feedback.
Participants are encouraged to use the Opportunity Discovery Canvas as a guide to
discuss their original ideas, the potential customers, stakeholders and other knowledge
sources they consulted, and what they learned from the out-of-the-building experience.
Participants should be prepared to discuss areas of uncertainty as well as the next steps
they intend to take.
These in-class presentations can be accomplished using Microsoft PowerPoint, Apple
Keynote, or other visual aids. Facilitators should discuss effective presentation strategies
with participants. Facilitators may also choose to invite local entrepreneurs to participate as
expert mentors who can offer additional guidance and support.
Facilitating Peer Workshops
Facilitators may consider using the following techniques as a guide to create a successful peer
workshopping session:
1. Begin by discussing the most recent application assignment with the whole class, giving participants
the opportunity to share challenges and opportunities they may have encountered during their most
recent “out-of-the-building” canvas experience.
Lesson 2: Recognizing
Opportunities
(Full Video: 59:07)
CH 2: 5:15-10:04 (4:49)
CH 3: 10:04-14:11 (4:07)
CH 4: 14:11-20:34 (6:23)
___________________________________
Total Time (15:19)
___________________________________
Lesson 3: Ideas into Action
(Full Video: 70:12)
CH 2: 5:19-10:28 (5:09)
CH 3: 10:28-18:22 (7:54)
CH 4: 18:22-24:21 (5:59)
CH 7: 0:00-7:39 (7:39)
Summary: 35:29-36:34 (1:05)
___________________________________
Total Time (27:46)
___________________________________
Lesson 4: Pursuit of Knowledge
(Full Video: 63:03)
CH 4: 22:04-38:04 (16:00)
CH 5: 0:00-1:32 (1:32)
CH 7: 8:02-23:43 (15:41)
___________________________________
Total Time (33:13)
___________________________________
Lesson 5: Creating Wealth
(Full Video: 61:29)
CH 1 pt. 2 11:11-17:25 (6:14)
CH 3 30:57-41:12 (10:15)
Summary: 19:17-20:17 (1:00)
___________________________________
Total Time (17:29)
___________________________________
Lesson 7: Creating Community
(Full Video: 88:58)
CH 5: 18:13-35:17 (17:04)
____________________________________
Total Time (17:04)
____________________________________
20
21
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
2. Split participants into small groups, such that each participant is from a different canvas/business
idea group. Participants can discuss their canvas process, provide peer-to-peer feedback, and/or
complete other related activities.
3. Some participants may choose to work on the Opportunity Discovery Process in groups. If so, give
participants time within their canvas groups to evaluate their most recent canvas iterations and
discuss next steps using the “Notes” section on the back of their canvas.
As participants share their experiences throughout the Opportunity Discovery Process, consider
the following questions and suggestions in order to encourage them to think critically and cope with
ambiguous, real-world circumstances, while also providing encouragement and support:
1. Test ideas: Encourage participants to design and conduct micro experiments that will enable them
to test their assumptions in the real world with minimal investment of time and money.
2. Overcoming fear: Speaking to strangers is often difficult, scary, and nerve-racking for first-time
entrepreneurs. However, participants can benefit from knowing that such conversations and the
associated fear are common and are part of the entrepreneurial journey. Encourage participants
and let them know that overcoming the fear of engaging potential customers and stakeholders
occurs through accumulated experience; the more they speak to strangers, the easier it becomes
and the better they become at it.
3. Think critically: People rarely behave as we predict, and, in many cases, they do not behave as
they say they will behave. Furthermore, those who provide information may have a biased opinion
or perspective. Consider the following questions:
Was the knowledge source you utilized reputable? Why or why not? How do you know?
What assumptions and beliefs might be driving their behavior or influencing their opinions about
your idea?
Is this source’s opinion reputable and relevant to your discovery process? Why or why not? How
do you know?
What inherent biases might the source hold? What assumptions and beliefs might be driving
these opinions?
While your first out-of-the-building interview experiences might have produced immediate,
positive feedback about your proposed solution from a few sources, there is still work to do.
4. Sample size is important: Good ideas are rarely obvious in their initial stage. The more potential
customers, stakeholders, and other sources the participants consult, the more likely they are to
discover a problem--solution fit. We recommend that each participant (or group) consult with at least
50 separate knowledge sources throughout the course.
Encourage participants to listen and to remain open-minded to tangential opportunities. In many
cases, the original idea is flawed; yet through persistence, unexpected opportunities often arise.
Participants should be encouraged to expand their list of potential customers, stakeholders, and
other knowledge sources rather than repeatedly talking to the same two or three people.
Encourage participants to be persistent, continuously getting out-of-the-building to interact with
more people who are interested in the problem that they want to solve.
5. What would Uncle Cleve do? Sometimes asking a question through a third-person perspective
can prompt ideas and suggestions that may not otherwise arise.
6. “Will someone steal my idea?” In some cases, participants may be reluctant to share their
problem-solving ideas for fear that their peers will steal the idea. First, verify that the participant’s
concern is legitimate. Remind him/her that the entrepreneurial process is “1% inspiration and 99%
perspiration.” The execution of an idea is far more important than the idea itself. Second, most
entrepreneurs are only able to achieve proof of concept for their ideas once they have spoken
with a sufficient amount of potential customers and other stakeholders to receive feedback and
suggestions. In order to follow this process themselves, participants ultimately must share their ideas
with others.
7. “I want to protect my idea.” If a participant still feels uncomfortable sharing his/her idea with the
class, acknowledge his/her concern. Discuss how this may affect the participant’s full participation in
the course. Then, present alternative options and action steps:
Suggest that the participant apply for a provisional patent of his/her idea. A patent protects
intellectual property, is inexpensive, and involves a simple application process.
Encourage the participant to pick a separate idea to use in the Ice House Opportunity Discovery
Process. The participant can then transfer the learning from this process to his/her original idea
privately.
Guide the participant to find an experienced mentor, entrepreneur, or subject matter expert who
can help navigate this important issue.
22
23
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
8. “I don’t have an idea for a solution to a problem. What should I do?” Some participants
may feel stuck and struggle to find problem-solving opportunities. Others may have had an idea
but decide that they like a peer’s idea better after hearing it in a class session. In either case,
the Opportunity Discovery Process offers participants a chance to join with a classmate who
already has a problem-solving idea (if he/she is willing to collaborate), while still building their
entrepreneurial skills. After all, a group requires several multi-skilled, entrepreneurial people to
develop an idea into a successful endeavor. Encourage participants in this position to think about
how their unique skills and talents can contribute to the group’s discovery process, without being
the actual innovator of the idea.
At the end of each application assignment, participants should complete a new iteration of their
canvas and be prepared to discuss with colleagues in the corresponding peer workshop. This
iteration should include the participant’s latest assumptions documented in the appropriate canvas
boxes, as well as additional analysis on the backside of the canvas.
Chalkboard Discussions
Peer Workshops are one of the most important elements of the Ice House Entrepreneurship
Program. However, Chalkboard Discussions can be a beneficial supplement for participants during
in-class sessions. These discussions provide an opportunity to review core concepts from the
chalkboard lessons, allowing participants to compare and contrast Ice House concepts with their
own experiences and prior knowledge. Chalkboard Discussions also enable participants to both
broaden and deepen their understanding of key concepts by applying them to their group projects,
as well as their professional and personal goals.
Facilitating Chalkboard Discussions
Facilitators are encouraged to prompt discussions by reviewing specific Chalkboard segments.
Lesson-specific discussion questions are included in the Facilitator Manual. These questions can
be used in class or as prompts in an online forum.
Facilitators should also invite participants to guide discussion of the key concepts and the topics
that most interested them. Consider asking participants to share what was most interesting,
surprising, or motivating to them about the main messages communicated in each lesson by the
Ice House entrepreneurs and/or Uncle Cleve. For instance:
Which concept from this Chalkboard Lesson was most intriguing to you? Why?
Which entrepreneur’s comments most sparked your interest in this lesson? Why?
How do the concepts in this lesson apply to an entrepreneurial mindset?
How does this portion of Uncle Cleve’s story resonate with your own life?
In this way, participants have autonomy over the specific direction of the discussion, while also
achieving the lesson-specific learning objectives set by the facilitator. These questions will
complement the suggested facilitator-generated discussion questions for each lesson that are
provided in the Course Assignments section of this manual.
The following questions can be used at the conclusion of Chalkboard Discussions to help
participants form connections with the core objectives of the Ice House program:
Why is learning about entrepreneurship important to you personally?
What are the underlying beliefs and assumptions that can influence your choices and push you
to succeed?
How can an entrepreneurial mindset be applied to your professional goals?
How can an entrepreneurial mindset be applied to your personal vision?
By relating the discussion back to each participant’s personal vision and goals, facilitators
encourage every participant to share ideas about why the Ice House core concepts are important
and/or interesting to him/her, even for those participants who often feel uncomfortable or unwilling to
participate in discussion activities.
Lesson-specific facilitator-generated discussion questions are located in the Course Assignments
section of this manual. These tools are optional and are merely intended to help facilitators spark
meaningful discussions if facilitators deem it necessary.
APPLICATION ASSIGNMENTS
Application Assignments challenge participants to apply the core Ice House concepts in real-world,
unpredictable circumstances that facilitate the development of entrepreneurial attitudes, behaviors,
and skills. Largely self-directed, the application assignments are designed to get participants “out
of the building,” immersing them in an iterative, experimental process that enables them to identify,
validate, and develop new opportunities.
Using the Opportunity Discovery Canvas as a guide, participants -- individually or in teams -- are
required to get out of the building to test their ideas by interacting with customers (i.e., the target
audience or anyone who may have the problem that the participants are attempting to solve) and
stakeholders (i.e., others who may also benefit from the proposed solution) that have an interest in
24
25
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
their product or service. These out-of-the-building experiences are essential to the entrepreneurial
process of validating a concept before making a significant investment of time and money.
In most cases, the participants’ original ideas are likely to contain flaws, yet the more they
listen and observe, the better they will understand the problem from their potential customer’s
perspective. And the better they understand the problem, the more likely they are to develop a
viable solution. These out-of-the-building experiences are essential to the entrepreneurial process
of validating a concept before making a significant investment of time and money.
Participants are also encouraged to seek additional knowledge and insight through interaction with
experienced entrepreneurs, subject matter experts, and other resources.
At the end of each Application Assignment, participants are encouraged to review and adjust their
Canvas assumptions based on customer feedback. Participants should also be prepared to discuss
their out-of-the-building experiences in Peer Workshop presentations.
Specific guidelines for the Application Assignments are included in the Course Assignments
section of this Manual.
THE ICE HOUSE OPPORTUNITY DISCOVERY CANVAS
The Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas is a tool designed to guide participants through the
Opportunity Discovery Process. Drawing on the work of Alexander Osterwalder’s Business Model
Canvas, the Opportunity Discovery Canvas encourages participants to think critically and manage
risks as they learn to identify and validate new opportunities within resource-constrained, uncertain
circumstances.
The Opportunity Discovery Canvas is divided into three primary sections designed to guide
participants through the three distinct phases of the Opportunity Discovery Process.
Phase one encourages participants to focus on the problem they intend to solve. Phase two
encourages participants to consider possible solutions. Phase three encourages participants to think
about how they might connect with others who may have the problem they intend to solve.
Working in small groups or alone, participants are asked to document their assumptions or “best
guesses” by addressing the questions within each of the canvas boxes. Once participants document
their assumptions in the appropriate boxes, they are expected to get out of the building to test their
assumptions by interviewing potential customers.
For example, after learning of a robbery at a local bank, Ice House Entrepreneur David Petite
envisioned a unique security device for ATM machines. As part of his discovery process, he
identified bank managers as potential customers that he could interview as a way to determine the
viability of his idea. He also identified law enforcement officials as potential stakeholders who could
help validate the viability of his idea. Through the process of interviewing potential customers and
stakeholders, David gained the confidence to develop a prototype of his concept.
In addition to interviewing potential customers and stakeholders, participants are also encouraged
to seek additional knowledge through interaction with experienced entrepreneurs, subject matter
experts, and other resources.
26
27
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
CONNECTION
SOLUTION
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
How did you encounter this
problem or unmet need?
Do other people have
this problem?
Why is this problem worth
solving?
Describe the people that
are most likely to have this
problem?
Think about age range,
gender, areas of interest,
profession, etc.
Which of these potential
“customers” can you most
easily connect with?
Describe other solutions
that are currently available?
Why is the current solution
inadequate?
How important is this
problem?
What is the single most
important feature of your
solution?
What is the most effective
way to demonstrate your
idea?
How will you know if others
are interested in your
solution?
How is your idea better
than existing solutions?
Describe the key
differences.
How will you know if others
value this improvement?
Will people be willing to
pay for your solution?
How often will they need
your solution?
How will you know that
your solution is valuable
to others?
How can you find more
people who may be
interested in your solution?
What methods of
communication will you
use to reach them?
What message do you
intend to convey?
How can you make it easy
for your customers to
purchase your solution?
For example, through a
retail store, online,
door-to-door sales, etc.
How are they currently
accessing a solution?
How will your customers
know they can rely on you?
How will you communicate
this message explicitly?
Why is this problem worth
solving?
Sample Canvas
Back of Canvas Analysis
The back side of each Canvas includes a “Notes” section designed to encourage participants to
analyze and reflect on what they are learning as they complete each iteration of their canvas. The
back of the canvas includes the following questions:
What have you learned and how has your idea changed in the most recent version of your
canvas?
Which of your assumptions were accurate and which of them have changed?
What are your next action steps?
Who do you still need to talk to and what knowledge gaps still need to be filled?
The Opportunity Discovery Process requires participants to continuously analyze and revise their
canvas assumptions based on what they are learning through the Opportunity Discovery Process.
As participants progress, their Canvas will continuously evolve as they continue to search for a
problem-solution fit.
When does the Opportunity Discovery Process end?
Generally the process ends in one of two ways: pivot or proceed. The individual or group either
decides they no longer want to pursue a particular solution, and they begin to search for other
problems to solve; or they have validated their concept, and people are beginning to pay for their
solution.
28
29
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
CANVAS IN ACTION
The following is a detailed explanation of each phase of the Opportunity Discovery Process. This
explanation includes example canvases that illustrate several iterations of the entrepreneurial
process for Jason Campbell, one of the Ice House Entrepreneurs.
Phase 1: Understanding the Problem
The first row of boxes (1 through 3) encourage participants to focus on the problem they intend
to solve or the unmet need they intend to fill. These initial questions are designed to gain an
“outside-in” perspective that enables participants to understand the problem through the eyes of
potential customers or stakeholders before prescribing a potential solution. While some participants
may already have a potential solution in mind, the emphasis here should be on accurately
understanding the problem.
In addition to the primary question within each box, additional questions or suggestions are
included to help guide the inquiry and discovery process. Participants should NOT be required
to answer the secondary questions, as they are intended merely as a guide to help participants
through the discovery process. These questions are also included in the Participant Workbook.
Box 1: Describe the problem you want to solve.
How did you encounter this problem or unmet need?
Do other people have this problem?
Why is this problem worth solving?
Box 2: Describe the type of people who have this problem.
Describe the people that are most likely to have this problem.
Think about age range, gender, areas of interest, profession, etc.
Which of these potential “customers” can you most easily connect with?
Box 3: How are they currently solving the problem?
Describe other solutions that are currently available.
Why is the current solution inadequate?
How important is this problem?
30
31
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
NOTES
1.
2.
3.
What have you learned and how has your idea changed in the most recent version of your canvas?
Which of your assumptions were accurate and which of them have changed?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
What are your next action steps? Who do you still need to talk to and what knowledge gaps still
need to be filled? How can you test your assumptions in the real world with limited time, money and
resources?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________
Additional Analysis
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
Example Notes 1
Not yet applicable - have not been out of building yet.
Speak to 5 building contractors to discuss problem, inquire about possible solu-
tions.
Questions: how often do sites need to be cleaned? Does cleaning require special
equipment like garbage dumpsters? Would I have to dispose of waste myself?
Talk to waste removal companies.
Identify areas where there are construction activities. Identify people we know
who may own small construction companies.
Identify people who may work in construction industry
Identify people who may work in related industries like carpentry, masonry
work, excavation, plumbing, electricians, bankers (who work with construction
loans).
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
Home-builders have difficulty
maintaining clean, organized
construction sites
Smaller construction
Companies and independent
Contractor
Not sure? Maybe owners are
doing it themselves?
CONNECTION
SOLUTION
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
32
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
Phase 2: Finding a Solution
The second row of boxes (4 through 6) are solution-oriented questions that encourage participants
to think about potential solutions, as well as the viability of their proposed solutions. Participants
are encouraged to test their ideas by interviewing potential customers and other stakeholders who
may have an interest in solving the problem at hand. In many (if not most) cases, the original idea
is likely to be flawed. Yet through this interactive discovery process unforeseen obstacles, as well
as unexpected opportunities, can be found.
Box 4: Describe your proposed solution.
What is the single most important feature of your solution?
What is the most effective way to demonstrate your idea?
How will you know if others are interested in your solution?
Box 5: How will your solution be different?
How is your idea better than existing solutions?
Describe the key differences.
How will you know if others value this improvement?
Box 6: Will people pay for your solution?
Will people be willing to pay for your solution?
How often will they need your solution?
How will you know that your solution is valuable to others?
34
35
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
SOLUTION
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
Home-builders have difficulty
maintaining clean, organized
construction sites
Smaller construction
Companies and independent
Contractors
Very small - one-man -
contracting Companies not
interested.
They do it themselves
Not sure? Maybe owners are
doing it themselves?
Small contractors
doing it themselves.
Reliable service
on-demand site
cleaning services
Reliable on-demand
site cleaning services
Yes - $20 per hour rate
CONNECTION
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
NOTES
1.
2.
3.
What have you learned and how has your idea changed in the most recent version of your canvas?
Which of your assumptions were accurate and which of them have changed?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
What are your next action steps? Who do you still need to talk to and what knowledge gaps still
need to be filled? How can you test your assumptions in the real world with limited time, money and
resources?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________
Additional Analysis
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
Example Notes 2
Yes - construction site cleaning seems to a real problem. Owners of construction
companies were more helpful/open than I expected. Small companies dont have
the staff, or much time to find outside help for site cleaning.
Construction sites almost always have garbage dumpsters on them, so this
shouldnt be a problem. Sometimes I may have to arrange dumpster drop
off/pick up (easy to do).
Need to determine what specific tools I need (like vacuums, brooms, buckets
and protective clothing, etc). Contact trash removal company for prices. Do I
need permits, if so who do I talk to? City building inspectors? Construction sites
have heavy equipment and expensive materials, do I need insurance? Confirm
with contractors, then find business insurance companies and determine costs.
Identify who in group will explore tools, permits, insurance, pricing etc.
Since contractors were so open and willing to talk to me, I think theres a fair
amount of interest in this service. The work is straightforward & satisfying,
and valuable enough to the contractors for a very reasonable $20 hourly rate.
This idea is definitely worth pursuing.
Will contractors be willing to pay an hourly rate? Wont they worry about
being overbilled, or people taking their time to perform the work?
36
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
Phase 3: Problem-Solution-Connection
Once a problem-solution fit has been confirmed, the third row of boxes (7 through 9) encourage
participants to think about broadening their reach by connecting with more people who may have
the problem they are trying to solve.
While participants will be asked to consider these connection questions as part of the group
application assignment in Lesson 6, we also encourage them to continuously test their ideas
and confirm a problem-solution fit (boxes 1 through 6) before investing too much time and effort
attempting to connect with a broader audience.
Box 7: How will potential customers know about your solution?
How can you find more people who may be interested in your solution?
What methods of communication will you use to reach them?
What message do you intend to convey?
Box 8: How will potential customers purchase your solution?
How can you make it easy for your customers to purchase your solution?
For example, through a retail store, online, door-to-door sales, etc.
How are they currently accessing a solution?
Box 9: Why will potential customers purchase your solution?
How will your customers know they can rely on you?
How will you communicate this message explicitly?
How will you communicate this message implicitly?
38
39
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
CONNECTION
SOLUTION
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
Home-builders have difficulty
maintaining clean, organized
construction sites
Small contractors
doing it themselves.
Reliable service
on-demand site
cleaning services
Reliable on-demand
site cleaning services
Yes - $20 per hour rate
Customers prefer to pay by
the job rather than
hourly rate
Simple one-page flyers,
word of mouth
Call on-demand
short notice.
Reliability is the key.
Customers must know that
we will complete jobs/projects
on time - no excuses.
Smaller construction
Companies and independent
Contractors
Very small - one-man -
contracting Companies not
interested.
They do it themselves
NOTES
1.
2.
3.
What have you learned and how has your idea changed in the most recent version of your canvas?
Which of your assumptions were accurate and which of them have changed?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
What are your next action steps? Who do you still need to talk to and what knowledge gaps still
need to be filled? How can you test your assumptions in the real world with limited time, money and
resources?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________
Additional Analysis
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
Example Notes 3
Customers prefer to pay by the project rather than by the hour. This makes
sense because its less risky for them (they dont have to worry about being
overbilled, etc).
But this means we have to be good at estimating how much time jobs will take,
so we dont end up working for pennies.
Reliability is definitely important because contractors have very tight
scheduling for the different phases of construction projects, showing the
property to potential customers, etc.
Need to determine how to connect with more customers, as well as identifying
other related services we can offer.
Need to determine pricing, document time spent to complete projects.
Need to plan for growth by recruiting more team members. Follow up with
other construction related companies to offer related services.
Talk to lawyer for basic legal advice.
May be able to set a project price - we manage the construction site cleaning
throughout the project without needing to be prompted by contractor (need to
remove this area of concern).
Need to improve messaging on flyer to let potential customers know we offer
other services as well (experiment with different service offerings, see what
people call back about). Need to figure out how to get other related companies
to promote/talk about our services.
41
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
OPTIONAL COURSE ELEMENTS
COMPANION TEXT
Inspired by the life story of Pulitzer nominee Clifton Taulbert, Who Owns the Ice House? - Eight
Life Lessons From An Unlikely Entrepreneur is a powerful and compelling story that captures the
essence of an entrepreneurial mindset and the unlimited opportunities it can provide.
Drawing on the wisdom he gained from his Uncle Cleve, Who Owns the Ice House? chronicles
Clifton Taulbert’s journey from his life in the Mississippi Delta at the height of legal segregation
to being recognized by Time Magazine as “one of our nation’s most outstanding emerging
entrepreneurs.” While Taulbert describes the life-changing influence of his Uncle Cleve, co-author
Gary Schoeniger captures the entrepreneurial life-lessons that can empower anyone to succeed.
The book serves to supplement the course materials while reinforcing the power of an
entrepreneurial mindset as a framework for thinking and acting that can empower anyone to
succeed. Participants who read the book will benefit from a deeper understanding of the content
and context, enabling them to more effectively relate Uncle Cleve’s story into their own lives.
REFLECTION ASSIGNMENTS: PERSONAL VISION STATEMENT
The Reflection Assignments encourage participants to reflect on the core concepts and how
they can be applied in a way that will enable participants to overcome obstacles and achieve
their own goals. Reflection is a cognitive process that promotes self-awareness and encourages
self-assessment. It is a form of personal response to experiences, situations, events, or new
information. Most importantly, it is a processing phase where thinking and learning occur, allowing
the participant to examine his or her beliefs, values, attitudes, and assumptions as they relate to
his or her goals.
To introduce the importance of reflection throughout the course, facilitators are encouraged to use
the following questions to spark discussion on day 1:
1. What subjects, topics, or issues matter most to you? What does success look like to
you?
2. What are the most important things you want to make happen in your life and in your
career?
3. What are the greatest obstacles preventing you from accomplishing your goals?
42
43
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
4. How will you overcome these obstacles in order to accomplish your goals?
5. What do you want to get out this course?
These questions encourage participants to think about the future they want to create, the obstacles
that stand in their way, and their expectations for persevering toward success. (If an expanded
delivery is utilized, these questions can be assigned as an introductory reflection exercise.
Additionally, an expanded delivery may enable facilitators to incorporate these and similar
questions into lesson-specific reflection assignments.)
In the recommended delivery of the Ice House Entrepreneurship Program, the Personal Vision
Statement serves as the primary reflection assignment. As a final assignment, the Personal Vision
Statement should describe participants’ visions for the future they want to create and how it may
have evolved as a result of what they have learned throughout the course. Participants should
develop a concrete roadmap detailing how they intend to apply the core concepts of the Ice
House Entrepreneurship Program to overcome obstacles and accomplish their goals. Additional
components of the Personal Vision Statement can include a reflection on which lessons and
entrepreneurs resonated most, why taking this course was important, how thought processes have
evolved throughout the course, and more. Specific guidelines for the Personal Vision Statement
are provided in the Assignments section of the Manual.
THE ICE HOUSE METHODOLOGY
THE IMPORTANCE OF PEER-TO-PEER LEARNING
Peer-to-peer learning and problem solving are essential aspects of the entrepreneurial learning
process, as they most accurately reflect the way in which entrepreneurs learn. Problem solving
in groups slows down the learning process, requiring participants to think critically about the
challenges at hand. Though working in groups can be difficult, this process is vital to developing an
entrepreneurial mindset.
In many cases, aspiring entrepreneurs quickly “fall in love” with their ideas. However, these ideas
are often vague and unclear at inception, and important details are easily overlooked. Without
consulting others before proceeding with an idea, it is easy for an entrepreneur’s objectivity to
become clouded, leading to costly mistakes.
When participants are forced to articulate the critical reasoning behind their ideas and the
anticipated results of their proposed actions, either verbally or on paper, they are able to clarify
their thought process. Participants are much less likely to maintain unreasonable assumptions
or overlook details when they must convince others of their reasoning and consider competing
viewpoints.
Furthermore, participants who have recently learned a certain concept can more easily remember
and communicate the path and reasoning that led to their understanding of the concept. Therefore,
when participants are impelled to explain their ideas in group discussions, their explanation often
helps their peers to learn more effectively.
Throughout the course, participants are encouraged to discuss the challenges they face and the
knowledge they gain from both the Chalkboard Lessons and the Opportunity Discovery Process.
Peer-to-peer learning should encourage participants to share the beliefs and assumptions that
either enhance or inhibit their ability to succeed. In this way, participants can elaborate and build on
each other’s ideas in order to create collective solutions to problems and challenges.
Peer-to-peer presentations and discussions should continue throughout the course, as the
participants review and revise their solutions based on knowledge gained through self-directed
learning, interactions with local entrepreneurs, and other community engagement activities.
44
45
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
THE IMPORTANCE OF COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Local entrepreneurs play a vital role in the successful implementation of the Ice House
Entrepreneurship Program, both as guest speakers as well as potential mentors and advisors.
Additionally, local entrepreneurs can participate during in-class discussions.
Facilitators and participants are encouraged to invite local entrepreneurs into the learning process.
And though it is helpful if the facilitator is connected with local entrepreneurs, the course is
designed to encourage participants to identify and interact with local entrepreneurs themselves.
As guest speakers, local entrepreneurs tell stories which provide vital reinforcement of key
concepts, motivating participants to act on their ideas. Local entrepreneurs can also play an
important role as expert mentors and advisors who provide critical guidance and support. And
despite not being immediately obvious, entrepreneurs can be found everywhere in communities
large and small, and they are usually willing to help.
One great way to identify and interact with local entrepreneurs is through networking. Most
communities have small business networking events that are likely to include entrepreneurs and
other subject matter experts who may be willing to share their knowledge and experience. As in
any entrepreneurial endeavor, persistence is the key.
Approaching an Entrepreneur
Successful entrepreneurs are busy people, yet they are often willing to help those who
demonstrate a sincere desire to learn. Below are a few suggestions that will help your participants
connect with local entrepreneurs who can provide valuable knowledge and insight:
When approaching an entrepreneur, whether via email, phone, social media, or in person,
participants should be prepared with specific questions and/or be ready to discuss the specific
knowledge and support they need from the entrepreneur in order to achieve their goals.
Provide participants with this paragraph to use as a template to engage with an entrepreneur.
“Hello, my name is _____________________, and I’m enrolled in the Ice House
Entrepreneurship Program at ______________________. We’re working on a group project,
and I was hoping I could ask you a few questions about your entrepreneurial experience.”
Just because an entrepreneur is successful does not mean he or she is unwilling to help.
Although they may be intimidated, participants should be encouraged to connect with successful
entrepreneurs in order to gain valuable feedback about their ideas and improve their networking
skills.
Being teachable is important. If participants act as if they already know everything, an experienced
entrepreneur will be less inclined to help them. Participants should be encouraged to listen more
and talk less.
Take an entrepreneur’s advice seriously. Participants who demonstrate a willingness to heed an
entrepreneur’s counseling are more likely to develop long-term mentoring relationships. Even
though participants are not expected to take any and all advice they receive, they should be
encouraged to let the entrepreneur know they have at least considered his or her advice.
Follow up. A simple “thank you” goes a long way. Whether the participants are interested in a
one-time meeting, a guest lecture, or a long-term mentoring relationship, they should let the
entrepreneur know that his or her time and effort are appreciated.
Preparing for a Guest Speaker
Guest lectures from local entrepreneurs are an important aspect of the Ice House Entrepreneurship
Program. Their stories help reinforce the key concepts while motivating participants to act on their
ideas. When inviting an entrepreneur into the classroom, a few simple guidelines will help keep the
presentations relevant and engaging:
Provide basic information about the presentation time and date, including directions, room
number, and contact information well in advance.
Let the entrepreneur know the amount of time allotted for his or her presentation.
Rather than dispensing advice, guest speakers should be encouraged to share their personal
experience as an entrepreneur. Ask them to spend a few minutes describing their background,
their business, and the events that led to them becoming an entrepreneur.
Ask them to describe specific challenges they faced and how they overcame them. Also, ask
them to describe unexpected opportunities they encountered along the way.
Encourage them to discuss how they learned to become a successful entrepreneur: influence of a
relative, guidance of a mentor, formal education, trial and error, etc.
Send a brief outline of the lesson you are currently working on, and ask the entrepreneur to share
his or her experience as it relates to the specific lesson.
46
47
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
Ask guest speakers to share one or two of the most important lessons they learned from their
entrepreneurial experience.
Note: These are basic suggestions to help make the guest lectures an effective part of the learning
experience. As the facilitator, you can modify the format and the questions to fit your specific
audience.
SAMPLE DELIVERY SCHEDULES
3-SESSION BOOT CAMP STYLE BLENDED DELIVERY
Pre-course assignments.
Note: Participants should obtain course materials two weeks prior to first session. Facilitators and
organizers should invite local entrepreneurs to participate as guest lecturers. This course can be
delivered over a single weekend (Friday evening - Sunday afternoon) or two weekends (Saturday
and Sunday plus the following Saturday).
Review welcome message, learning objectives and delivery schedule.
View Chalkboards (essential):
Introduction Chalkboard (Full: 35:40. Abr: 17:28.)
Lesson 1 Chalkboard (Full: 47:21. Abr: 15:21.)
Lesson 2 Chalkboard (Full: 59:07. Abr: 15:19.)
Read PDF description available on LMS -- “Introduction to the Opportunity Discovery Process.”
Brainstorm problem you would like to solve or other business ideas to use in the Opportunity
Discovery Canvas process.
Prepare to present your business idea/concept and address canvas questions during first
session
Optional:
Read Who Owns The Ice House? -- Preface and Introduction, Chapters 1 and 2.
In-class session #1 (approximately 5-6 hours)
Group introductions & learning expectations (:45).
48
49
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
Review and discuss Video Chalkboard concepts Introduction, Lesson 1 & 2 (1:00)
Peer Workshop:
Introduce and discuss Opportunity Discovery Canvas & Process (1:00)
Initial “pitch” presentations and peer feedback (3 - 5 minutes each, 1:00 +/-)
Revise initial Canvas assumptions as needed (all Phases) (:30)
Discuss guidelines for “out of the building” Application Assignment - establish number of
interviews to be completed. (:30)
Optional:
Guest speaker(s) - Highly recommended
Complete Introduction Reflection Assignment as a class discussion
Discuss book relevance & overarching concepts: how do entrepreneurs manage to identify,
evaluate and develop opportunities?
Homework & outside activities
View Chalkboards (essential):
Lesson 3 Chalkboard (Full: 70:12. Abr: 27:46.)
Lesson 4 Chalkboard (Full: 63:03. Abr: 33:13.)
Complete at least one Canvas iteration of Phase 1, Phase 2, OR Phase 3 Canvas Assignment,
depending on individual progress.
Conduct out-of-the-building customer/stakeholder interviews.
Seek out additional knowledge from experienced entrepreneurs, mentors and other
resources.
In-class session #2 (3 - 4 hours)
Review and discuss Video Chalkboard concepts from Lessons 3 & 4
Peer Workshop
Discuss “out of the building” canvas experiences -- challenges, obstacles and
opportunities (informal presentations). Additional peer feedback.
Revise Canvas. Decide whether to pivot or proceed with idea.
Discuss next steps. Identify knowledge gaps, additional customers, stakeholders, and
subject matter experts to pursue.
Optional:
Guest speaker(s) - Highly recommended
Discuss book relevance & overarching concepts.
Homework & outside activities
Participants should complete at least two Canvas iterations of Phase 1, Phase 2, OR Phase 3
Canvas Assignment, depending on individual progress.
Continue out-of-the-building customer/stakeholder interviews.
Seek out additional knowledge from experienced entrepreneurs, mentors and other
resources.
Optional:
Participants prepare formal Final Presentation on evolution of their Canvas processes.
Complete Personal Vision Statement.
View Chalkboard Lessons (not required, but useful):
Lesson 5 Chalkboard (Full: 61:29. Abr: 17:29.)
50
51
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lesson 6 Chalkboard (Full: 56:26. Abr: 18:27.)
Lesson 7 Chalkboard (Full: 88:58. Abr: 17:04.)
In-class session #3 (3 - 4 hours)
Peer Workshop
Discuss “out of the building” canvas experiences -- challenges, obstacles and opportunities
(informal presentations). Additional peer feedback.
Revise Canvas. Decide whether to pivot or proceed with idea.
Participants discuss evolution of their Canvas processes and next post-course action steps.
Optional:
Guest speaker(s) - Highly recommended.
Formal final presentations (5 - 10 minutes each).
Go back out of the building and complete another Canvas iteration during the session.
Participants share Personal Vision Statements.
Review and discuss Video Chalkboard concepts from Lessons 5 through 8.
Discuss book relevance & overarching concepts
Homework & outside activities (Post-course)
Continue Opportunity Discovery Process.
Get out-of-the-building to complete more canvas iterations.
Interview potential customers/stakeholders and seek additional sources of knowledge.
View remaining Chalkboard Lessons:
Lesson 5 Chalkboard (Full: 61:29. Abr: 17:29.)
Lesson 6 Chalkboard (Full: 56:26. Abr: 18:27.)
Lesson 7 Chalkboard (Full: 88:58. Abr: 17:04.)
Lesson 8 Chalkboard (102:24).
52
53
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
SAMPLE SYLLABUS SCHEDULE - 6 WEEK BLENDED
CLASSROOM DELIVERY
HOMEWORK
Note: Participants should obtain course materials two weeks prior to first session
Review the welcome message, course overview, and delivery schedule
Login to learning management system (LMS).
View Introduction Chalkboard (Full: 35:40. Abr: 17:28.)
View Lesson 1 Chalkboard (Full: 47:21. Abr: 15:21.)
View Lesson 2 Chalkboard (Full: 59:07. Abr: 15:19.)
Optional: Read Who Owns the Ice House? - Preface and Introduction, Chapters 1 and 2
WEEK 1
Session 1
(2 - 3 hours each)
Course overview, learning objectives, syllabus review, instructor contact info, tech support, ice
breakers
Review and discuss Chalkboards- Introduction through Lesson 2
Introduce Opportunity Discovery Canvas
Discuss guidelines for Pre-Canvas Application Assignments
WEEK 2
Homework
View Lesson 3 Chalkboard (Full: 70:12. Abr: 27:46.)
View Lesson 4 Chalkboard (Full: 63:03. Abr: 33:13.)
Complete pre-Canvas Application Assignment. (Brainstorm problem you would like to solve or
other business ideas to use in the canvas process. Create first “rough sketch” of canvas before
class.)
Optional: Review PDF description available on LMS -- “Introduction to the Opportunity
Discovery Process”
Optional: Read Who Owns the Ice House? – Chapters 3 and 4
Optional: Complete Introduction Reflection Assignment.
Session 2
Review and discuss Chalkboards- Lessons 3 and 4
Peer Workshop: Discuss Pre-Canvas Application Assignment -- potential challenges,
obstacles and opportunities.
Initial business idea pitches and peer feedback.
Participants revise first “rough sketch” of canvas before the end of class.
Discuss guidelines for out-of-the-building application assignments.
One iteration of canvas = completing one application assignment. (Phase 1: focused on the
problem. Phase 2: focused on the solution. Phase 3: focused on the connection with customers.)
Optional: Guest speaker (highly recommended).
Optional: participants form canvas groups (2-4 per group) based on business ideas instead of
working as individuals on canvas process
54
55
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
WEEK 3
Homework
View Lesson 5 Chalkboard (Full: 61:29. Abr: 17:29.)
Complete at least one Canvas iteration of Phase 1 OR Phase 2 Canvas Assignment, depending
on individual progress.
Optional: Read Who Owns the Ice House? – Chapter 5.
Session 3
Review and discuss Chalkboard- Lesson 5
Peer Workshop. Discuss application assignment and “out-of-the-building” canvas
experience – challenges, obstacles and opportunities. Receive feedback from colleagues.
Focus of discussion determined by individual participant progress in canvas process.
Reinforce guidelines for application assignments.
Optional: Guest speaker (highly recommended).
WEEK 4
Homework
View Lesson 6 Chalkboard (Full: 56:26. Abr: 18:27.)
Complete at least one Canvas iteration of Phase 1, Phase 2, OR Phase 3 Canvas Assignment,
depending on individual progress.
Optional: Read Who Owns the Ice House? – Chapter 6.
Session 4
Review and discuss Chalkboard- Lesson 6
Peer Workshop. Discuss application assignment and “out-of-the-building” canvas
experience – challenges, obstacles and opportunities. Receive additional feedback from
colleagues. Focus of discussion determined by individual participant progress in canvas
process.
Optional: Guest speaker (highly recommended).
WEEK 5
Homework
View Lesson 7 Chalkboard (Full: 88:58. Abr: 17:04.)
Complete at least two Canvas iterations of Phase 2 OR Phase 3 Canvas Assignment,
depending on individual progress.
Optional: Read Who Owns the Ice House? – Chapter 7.
Session 5
Review and discuss Chalkboard- Lesson 7
Peer Workshop. Discuss application assignment and “out-of-the-building” canvas
experience – challenges, obstacles and opportunities. Receive additional feedback from
colleagues. Focus of discussion determined by individual participant progress in canvas
process.
Optional: Guest speaker (highly recommended).
Optional: Introduce Final Canvas Presentation guidelines.
Optional: Introduce Final Personal Vision Statement guidelines.
56
57
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
WEEK 6
Homework
Complete at least two Canvas iterations of Phase 2 OR Phase 3 Canvas Assignment,
depending on individual progress.
Optional: View Lesson 8 Chalkboard (102:24).
Optional: Read Who Owns the Ice House? – Chapter 8.
Optional: Prepare for Final Canvas Presentation
Optional: Complete Personal Vision Statement
Session 6
Peer Workshop. Discuss application assignment and “out-of-the-building” canvas experience
– challenges, obstacles and opportunities. Receive final feedback from colleagues. Focus of
discussion determined by individual participant progress in canvas process.
Participants discuss next action steps in building their ideas.
Course conclusion: Review course content – tie back to main themes and skills acquired.
Optional: Guest speaker (highly recommended).
Optional: Final Canvas Presentations – how business ideas have evolved through the
Opportunity Discovery Process.
Optional: Participants share Personal Vision Statements
Optional: Review and discuss Chalkboard- Lesson 8
COURSE ASSIGNMENTS
The following assignments are written to the perspective of course participants just as they
appear in the participant workbook. The assignments are included in this Manual to give
facilitators a comprehensive understanding of the work participants should complete throughout
the course. This section provides facilitators with a choice between using general assignment
recommendations or specific assignment instructions as participants embark on the Opportunity
Discovery Process. Based on facilitator discretion and preferred technique, the extent to which
these assignments are utilized may vary. Optional assignments that encourage reflection and class
presentations are also included at the end of this section.
APPLICATION ASSIGNMENTS
General Guidelines
Application Assignments provide an opportunity to get “out of the building” and apply
course concepts in real-world circumstances -- a process that will enable you to develop an
entrepreneurial mindset. Also known as the Ice House Opportunity Discovery Process, Application
Assignments are designed to help you identify and evaluate new opportunities through a process
of interaction and observation, experimentation and adaptation. They are also designed to
demonstrate the process that enables entrepreneurs to bootstrap their way into business without
relying on outside investment or conventional loans.
Using the Opportunity Discovery Canvas as a guide, these assignments will enable you to test
your ideas through face-to-face interaction and experimentation with potential customers and other
stakeholders who may have an interest in your product or service. The overall objective is to test
your ideas before making a significant investment of time and money. It is a vital process, one that
can help you avoid common missteps and unexpected pitfalls. It is also a process that can reveal
unforeseen opportunities that may otherwise be overlooked.
The first step is to document your initial assumptions or “best guesses” using the Opportunity
Discovery Canvas as a guide. Once you have documented your assumptions on the Canvas,
the next step is to go out of the building and identify potential “customers” (i.e., the target
audience or anyone who may have the problem that the participants are attempting to solve) and
“stakeholders” (i.e., others who may also benefit from the proposed solution) who may have an
interest in solving the problem at hand. Using the Canvas questions as a guide, conduct face-to-
face interviews with these individuals to test the validity of your idea.
Throughout the Ice House Entrepreneurship Program, be prepared to present on the evolution of
58
59
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
your ideas and to discuss the canvas process with peers. You should complete several iterations
of your Canvas throughout the Opportunity Discovery Process, continuously analyzing and revising
your ideas based on the knowledge you acquire from potential customers and feedback you receive
during Peer Workshops. The Canvas boxes provide an opportunity to record your current reasoning
and adjust your strategy based on customer feedback. In the Notes section on the back side of the
Canvas worksheet, you should reflect upon how your business idea is evolving and how you might
approach the Discovery Process differently in your next iteration.
This process may continue well beyond this course until you have validated your idea, and people
are beginning to pay for your solution; or until you decide to stop pursuing a particular solution, and
instead search for other problems to solve.
Things to keep in mind:
Overcoming fear. Speaking to strangers is often difficult, scary, and nerve-racking for first-time
entrepreneurs. However, such conversations and the associated fear are common and are part of
the entrepreneurial journey. Overcoming the fear of engaging potential customers and stakeholders
occurs through accumulated experience; the more you speak to strangers, the easier it becomes
and the better you become at it.
Sample size is important. Experienced entrepreneurs understand the value of speaking to a wide
range of potential customers and stakeholders before making a significant investment in an idea.
We recommend speaking with 25 - 50 potential customers throughout the duration of the course,
depending on the delivery timeframe.
Listen. Inexperienced entrepreneurs often “fall in love” with their ideas without any real evidence
that they are actually solving a problem or meeting a need. This tendency often creates a bias, one
that can blind us to unforeseen pitfalls as well as unexpected opportunities.
Through a process of interviewing, asking probing questions, and active listening, we can avoid
unforeseen pitfalls and minimize risk while significantly increasing our chances of success. And,
in some cases, this process can also reveal unanticipated opportunities. Here is a short list of
questions and strategies to deploy with potential customers:
Discuss the problem you intend to solve. Do they share your frustration?
Evaluate whether the problem is important to them. What evidence do you have?
Communicate your idea (proposed solution) and listen to their feedback. Does your solution
make sense?
Ask “why,” “why not,” and “what-if” questions.
Ask if they know of an additional person or knowledge resource that might help you with your
idea.
The Opportunity Discovery Process
The Canvas is divided into three sections. General descriptions of all three phases, in addition to
corresponding assignments with specific directives, are provided below:
Problem. The first section of the Canvas is designed to focus your attention on the problem you
are trying to solve. The questions are designed to help you understand the problem from the
customer’s point of view. While some may already have a solution in mind, these first questions
can help you determine if the problem is really worth solving before investing in a solution.
Remember to be objective and keep an open mind. At this stage, listening is more important than
selling.
Solution. The second section of the Canvas is designed to focus on the solution. Once you
understand the problem from the customer’s point of view, you will be in a much better position to
develop a solution. Examine your notes from your face-to-face interactions as you begin to develop
a proposed solution. Again using the Canvas questions as a guide, document your assumptions
about your proposed solution. Remember, you are looking for evidence that customers will actually
pay for your product or service before you invest lots of time and money in your idea. Here again it
is important to keep an open mind. In many cases, these interactions reveal unexpected pitfalls as
well as unanticipated opportunities.
Connection. Once you have determined that you have developed a viable solution, the third
section of the Canvas is designed to shift your focus towards connecting with more people who
may be interested in your product or service. Here it is important to stay focused on sections one
and two of the Canvas, confirming that you have a problem--solution fit before proceeding to the
connection phase.
60
61
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
CONNECTION
SOLUTION
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
SPECIFIC ASSIGNMENTS
PRE-CANVAS ASSIGNMENT
Problems are often opportunities in disguise. Entrepreneurs are problem solvers. The secret to
their success lies in their ability to identify and solve problems regardless of what they have to work
with or where they start.
Directive: Identify problems, frustrations, or unmet needs that you have encountered in your
personal or professional lives. Select the problem that is most important to you and begin to
formulate business ideas to solve this problem. Document initial assumptions about your idea in
boxes 1 through 9 (all three phases) of the Opportunity Discovery Canvas.
Back of the Canvas Analysis: Complete the Notes section on the back side of the Canvas
worksheet. In the “Additional Analysis” section of Notes, consider the following questions:
Why is the solution to this problem important to you?
Do other people have this problem?
How are they currently solving the problem?
How might you offer a better solution?
Discuss the problem with friends, family members, and others who may also have an interest in
solving the problem. Be prepared to pitch your idea in an informal setting to your colleagues.
62
63
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
CONNECTION
SOLUTION
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
NOTES
1.
2.
3.
What have you learned and how has your idea changed in the most recent version of your canvas?
Which of your assumptions were accurate and which of them have changed?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
What are your next action steps? Who do you still need to talk to and what knowledge gaps still
need to be filled? How can you test your assumptions in the real world with limited time, money and
resources?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________
Additional Analysis
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
64
65
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
PHASE 1 ASSIGNMENT
Now it’s time to get out of the building and “hit the bricks” to begin testing your ideas in the
real world. In this initial phase of the Opportunity Discovery Process, the goal is to test your
assumptions by pitching your ideas and interviewing a variety of potential customers and other
stakeholders who may also have an interest in the problem you are trying to solve. Finally, consider
looking beyond potential customers and searching for additional information from other sources of
knowledge.
Objective 1
Identify potential customers and other stakeholders (i.e., the people you described in box 2 of
your canvas) who may have an interest in solving the problem at hand. Using the questions in
canvas boxes 1 through 3 as your guide, conduct face-to-face interviews with approximately 10-15
potential customers.
Engage the potential customer or stakeholder:
Discuss the problem you intend to solve. Do they share your frustration? Did they mention other
problems that may be worth solving?
Evaluate whether the problem is important to them. What evidence do you have?
How are they currently solving the problem?
Ask if they know of an additional person or knowledge resource that might help you with your
idea.
Objective 2 (Optional)
Identify additional sources of knowledge in your general area of interest (besides potential
customers) that will help you better understand the problem you are trying to solve as well as what
solutions, if any, currently exist. These additional sources of knowledge may include, but are not
limited to:
Experienced entrepreneurs
Small business owners
Industry experts
Online resources (accredited informational websites, policy journals, newspaper articles,
reputable blogs)
Print resources (books, encyclopedias, manuals)
Other advisers and mentors
Engage with the Knowledge Source:
Evaluate what specific information you can acquire from each source.
Is this source reputable? Why or Why not?
What solutions, if any, currently exist? Are the existing solutions adequate?
Directive: Review your initial assumptions and revise boxes 1 through 3 (phase 1) of your
Opportunity Discovery Canvas based on what you have learned.
Back of the Canvas Analysis: Complete the Notes section on the back side of the Canvas
worksheet. In the “Additional Analysis” section of Notes, consider the following questions:
How would you rate your customers’ level of interest in the problem? (strongly interested,
somewhat interested, not interested, unclear?)
Is the problem you have identified worth solving? What evidence do you have?
Why is the solution to this problem important to you?
Do other people have this problem? If so, how are they currently solving the problem?
How might you offer a better solution?
What, if anything, surprised you the most from this interview experience?
66
67
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
CONNECTION
SOLUTION
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
NOTES
1.
2.
3.
What have you learned and how has your idea changed in the most recent version of your canvas?
Which of your assumptions were accurate and which of them have changed?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
What are your next action steps? Who do you still need to talk to and what knowledge gaps still
need to be filled? How can you test your assumptions in the real world with limited time, money and
resources?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________
Additional Analysis
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
68
69
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
PHASE 2 ASSIGNMENT
Previously, you have used the Opportunity Discovery Canvas to test initial assumptions about your
business idea and understand the problem you are trying to solve. Now it’s time to go back out
of the building and shift your focus to the solution. Use the canvas to help guide your search for
validation of a problem--solution fit. In this phase of the Opportunity Discovery Process, the goal is
to continue testing your assumptions by interviewing more potential customers and stakeholders.
You should also consider looking beyond potential customers and searching for additional
information from other sources of knowledge as you progress towards a problem-solution fit.
Objective 1
Identify and interview 15-20 more potential customers and other stakeholders (i.e., the people you
described in box 2 of your Canvas).
Engage the potential customer or stakeholder:
Discuss the problem you intend to solve. Do they share your frustration? Did they mention other
problems that may be worth solving?
Evaluate whether the problem is important to them. What evidence do you have?
How are they currently solving the problem?
Ask if your proposed solution makes sense.
Ask if they know of an additional person or knowledge resource that might help you with your
idea.
Objective 2 (Optional)
Identify additional sources of knowledge in your general area of interest (besides potential
customers) that will help you better understand the problem you are trying to solve as well as what
solutions, if any, currently exist. These additional sources of knowledge may include, but are not
limited to:
Experienced entrepreneurs
Small business owners
Industry experts
Online resources (accredited informational websites, policy journals, newspaper articles,
reputable blogs)
Print resources (books, encyclopedias, manuals)
Other advisers and mentors
Engage with the Knowledge Source:
Evaluate what specific information you can acquire from each source.
Is this source reputable? Why or Why not?
What solutions, if any, currently exist? Are the existing solutions adequate?
How might you offer a better solution?
Directive: Review your assumptions and revise boxes 1 through 6 (phases 1 and 2) of your
Opportunity Discovery Canvas based on what you have learned.
Back of the Canvas Analysis: Complete the Notes section on the back side of the Canvas
worksheet. In the “Additional Analysis” section of Notes, consider the following questions:
How would you rate your customers’ level of interest in the problem or solution? (strongly
interested, somewhat interested, not interested, unclear?)
Is the problem you have identified worth solving? What evidence do you have?
What, if anything, surprised you the most from this interview experience?
Are you confident in your proposed solution or do adjustments need to be made? What additional
knowledge is required?”
Who else should you include in your success network? How can these individuals provide new
value?
What methods will you use to expand your network? (Ex. consider attending a local business
networking event or contacting a small business consultancy.)
70
71
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
CONNECTION
SOLUTION
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
NOTES
1.
2.
3.
What have you learned and how has your idea changed in the most recent version of your canvas?
Which of your assumptions were accurate and which of them have changed?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
What are your next action steps? Who do you still need to talk to and what knowledge gaps still
need to be filled? How can you test your assumptions in the real world with limited time, money and
resources?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________
Additional Analysis
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
72
73
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
PHASE 3 ASSIGNMENT
Previously, you have used the Opportunity Discovery Canvas to help guide your search for
confirmation of a problem--solution fit. Once you are confident that people will pay for your product
or service, it’s time to focus on phase 3 of the Canvas. Here, you will begin to think about how
you can connect with a broader pool of potential customers and stakeholders. We will continue
to reinforce the importance of action combined with knowledge as the engine that drives the
entrepreneurial process.
Objective 1
Identify and interview 15-20 more potential customers and other stakeholders.
Engage the potential customer or stakeholder:
Communicate your proposed solution and listen to their feedback.
Using the canvas as a guide, ask specific questions drawn from boxes 7 through 9.
If necessary, revisit questions you asked in previous canvas iterations.
Ask if they know of an additional person or knowledge resource that might help you with your
idea.
Objective 2 (Optional)
Identify additional sources of knowledge in your general area of interest that will help you solve the
unanswered questions outlined in boxes 7 through 9 of your Opportunity Discovery Canvas. These
additional sources of knowledge may include, but are not limited to:
Experienced entrepreneurs
Small business owners
Industry experts
Online resources (accredited informational websites, policy journals, newspaper articles,
reputable blogs)
Print resources (books, encyclopedias, manuals)
Other advisers and mentors
Engage with the Knowledge Source:
Evaluate what specific information you can acquire from each source.
Determine how similar businesses communicate with their customers and deliver their
solution.
How is your idea unique from the products or services of existing businesses?
Identify additional knowledge sources (people or other resources) you know of that might be
able to help you accomplish your goals.
Directive: Review your assumptions and revise boxes 1 through 9 (all three Canvas phases) of
your Opportunity Discovery Canvas based on what you have learned.
Back of the Canvas Analysis: Complete the Notes section on the back side of the Canvas
worksheet. In the “Additional Analysis” section of Notes, consider the following questions:
How would you rate your customers’ level of interest in your revised solution? (strongly
interested, somewhat interested, not interested, unclear?)
Are you confident in your proposed solution or do adjustments need to be made?
Are there enough customers to make your efforts worthwhile?
Do you need to revise the way you communicate your message based on customer
feedback?
Who else should you include in your success network? How can these individuals provide
new value?
What methods will you use to expand your network? (Ex. consider attending a local business
networking event or contacting a small business consultancy.)
74
75
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
NOTES
1.
2.
3.
What have you learned and how has your idea changed in the most recent version of your canvas?
Which of your assumptions were accurate and which of them have changed?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
What are your next action steps? Who do you still need to talk to and what knowledge gaps still
need to be filled? How can you test your assumptions in the real world with limited time, money and
resources?
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________
Additional Analysis
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
CONNECTION
SOLUTION
PROBLEM
Ice House Opportunity Discovery Canvas
1. Describe the problem you
want to solve.
2. Describe the type of people
who have this problem.
3. How are they currently
solving the problem?
4. Describe your proposed
solution.
5. How will your solution
be different?
6. Will people pay for your
solution?
7. How will potential customers
know about your solution?
8. How will potential customers
purchase your solution?
9. Why will potential customers
purchase your solution?
76
77
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
FACILITATING APPLICATION ASSIGNMENTS
Note to facilitator: The Opportunity Discovery Process can be condensed or expanded based on
the specific needs of the class. Use of these specific Application Assignments will depend upon
the length of delivery schedule and is up to the discretion of the facilitator. These assignment
sequences are only suggestions; facilitators will use their own discretion to determine which
assignments to implement. More detailed recommendations of assignment sequences can be
viewed in the sample delivery schedules.
Following each class session, participants should complete the assignment for the Canvas phase
that best suits their individual progress on their business idea. For instance, participants who
are still formulating their ideas should focus on phase 1 of the Canvas, while those who already
have a problem--solution fit and/or have found paying customers should focus on phases 2 and
3. Completing any of these assignments once is equivalent to completing one Canvas iteration.
However, participants can also choose to complete more than one iteration and/or more than one
Canvas phase assignment before each class session.
Recommendations for Facilitator:
1. Boot Camp (3-day or 3-session) Format:
On day 1, participants should document their initial assumptions on the Canvas during a peer
workshop, and they should pitch ideas to the class (this can be modeled off of the pre-Canvas
assignment).
Before day 2, participants should complete one Canvas iteration in phases 1, 2, or 3, depending
on their individual progress.
Before day 3, participants should complete two Canvas iterations in phases 2 or 3, depending
on their individual progress. Participants should prepare to present the evolution of their ideas
throughout the course to the class.
2. Short Course (6-week) Format:
Before week 2, participants should complete the pre-Canvas assignment.
In week 2, participants should learn the Opportunity Discovery Process and document their
initial assumptions on the Canvas during a peer workshop.
Before week 3, participants should complete at least one iteration of the phase 1 or phase 2
Canvas assignment, depending on their individual progress.
Before week 4, participants should complete at least one iteration of the phase 1, phase 2, or
phase 3 Canvas assignment, depending on their individual progress.
Before week 5, participants should complete at least two iterations of the phase 2 or phase 3
Canvas assignment, depending on their individual progress.
Before week 6, participants should complete at least two iterations of the phase 2 or phase 3
Canvas assignment, depending on their individual progress. Participants should prepare to make
a final presentation on the evolution of their ideas throughout the course.
78
79
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
OPTIONAL ASSIGNMENTS AND COURSE MATERIALS
FACILITATOR GENERATED DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
Introduction
1. What do you think is required to succeed as an entrepreneur (e.g., brains, innate ability, luck,
money, risk tolerance, patentable idea, etc.)?
2. What do you see as the greatest obstacle(s) to becoming an entrepreneur?
3. What is a mindset? Why is it important to succeeding as an entrepreneur, in your career, and in
your life?
4. What factors influence our mindset? How does our mindset affect the choices we
make?
5. How do our beliefs and assumptions about the world and ourselves affect our decisions?
Lesson 1 - The Power to Choose
1. What social or environmental factors influence our choices in our culture today? Please provide
examples.
2. What are the underlying beliefs and assumptions that cause us to react or respond? How can
responding rather than reacting empower you?
3. Describe the difference between a person with an internal and an external locus of control. Why is
this distinction important?
4. How does an internal locus of control influence our decisions? How can this shift in awareness alter
your professional goals?
5. Why is vision important to an entrepreneurial mindset? How does having a vision influence our
choices?
Lesson 2 - Recognizing Opportunities
1. How does the assumption that problems are potential opportunities empower an
entrepreneur?
2. Identify a successful business that offers a simple solution to an everyday problem.
What problem is the business solving for its customers? Is the business successful because
of the idea itself, or because of how the idea is executed?
3. Rather than searching for big ideas that involve breakthrough technologies, the vast majority of
entrepreneurs pursue opportunities that are small, and highly uncertain. Entrepreneurs often have
to start a business to discover much larger opportunities that would otherwise be invisible. Describe
the concept of opportunistic adaptation. How does opportunistic adaptation differ from in-depth
planning?
4. Describe the characteristics of an enthusiastic and somewhat inexperienced entrepreneur. How
does the lack of experience sometimes enable entrepreneurs to identify identify opportunities that
those with more experience may overlook?
5. Why is it important to identify a problem first, then to provide a solution? Why is objectivity important
to an entrepreneur?
Lesson 3 - Ideas into Action
1. What do you think are the greatest barriers to entry for becoming an entrepreneur? Why? Which
barriers are more powerful, internal or external?
2. Why is bootstrapping important to an entrepreneur? How can the lack of resources become an
advantage to an entrepreneur?
3. How do customers determine the validity of our ideas? How can proving your concept increase
confidence while reducing the risk or uncertainty of a new venture?
4. “Courage is not the absence of fear, but the willingness to forge ahead in spite of it.” What does this
statement mean to you? Why is it important with regard to an entrepreneurial mindset?
5. How do entrepreneurs with limited resources identify and pursue opportunities? How do those
who have nothing, create something? How can you apply this method of bootstrapping to your
Opportunity Discovery Process?
80
81
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
6. Describe the difference between a fixed and a growth mindset. Provide an example of each
from your own life or from your social observations. How do fixed and growth mindsets relate to
entrepreneurship?
Lesson 4 - Pursuit of Knowledge
1. Why is a growth mindset important to an entrepreneurial mindset, curiosity, and the pursuit of
knowledge?
2. Ryan Blair, Rodney Walker, and Jason Campbell all explain how their actions as young people
reinforced their old beliefs. How did an entrepreneurial mindset influence their approach to learning
over time? How did their perceptions of their own abilities change?
3. What opportunities did Brian Scudamore discover once he had started his business?
How would careful planning have increased his ability to succeed? How could it have
hindered or discouraged him from starting his business?
How did he learn through interaction, observation, experimentation, and adaptation?
4. What is the difference between formal and informal learning? How can an understanding
of both types of learning affect the development and deployment of an entrepreneurial
mindset?
5. How does the process of experimentation help entrepreneurs distinguish beliefs and assumptions
from facts? How does the process of experimentation minimize their risks?
6. What is the difference between an intrinsic and an extrinsic motivation to learn? Why is this
distinction important?
7. How will you apply the combination of knowledge and effort to achieve your personal
vision?
Lesson 5 - Creating Wealth
1. Please define the following terms and provide examples of each:
Income
Expense
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
Asset
Liability
2. Describe the difference between spending and investing.
Why is this important to an entrepreneur? How can this concept be applied to our use of
time?
3. How will you invest your time and money so that you can accomplish your goals and personal vision
with limited resources?
4. How can an entrepreneurial mindset affect your ability to create wealth?
5. To what extent is the ability to create wealth important to you? Please explain.
6. What is the greatest barrier to creating wealth that stands in your way, and how will you overcome
it?
Lesson 6 - Building Your Brand
1. What are the two components of a brand? Why is branding important to an aspiring
entrepreneur?
2. Why is it important to understand your customer’s point of view? How can you be sure that
customers will behave and act as they say they will?
3. What is your personal brand and how will you communicate it to your peers, mentors, and
colleagues?
4. Describe the concept of branding by default and provide a real-world example of it. How can you
apply this concept to success in your Opportunity Discovery Process?
82
83
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
5. Describe an example of an explicit message you have heard or experienced. This message may
have been used in an advertisement, by an organization, or by a person that you know or have
observed.
Describe an example of an implicit message you have heard or experienced.
Which of your two examples is more powerful? Why?
6. Identify a business that has a good reputation. What message do they communicate?
How do they communicate their message?
How is their message (what they say about themselves) consistent with their reputation
(what their customers says about them)?
7. Where do entrepreneurs get their confidence? Are they born with it or can it be developed over
time? Why is this important to building a brand?
8. What actionable steps can you take in order to develop your confidence as an
entrepreneur?
Lesson 7 - Creating Community
1. What is an “intentional community”? Why is this concept important to an entrepreneurial
mindset?
2. If you were to hire employees, what knowledge, behavior, experience, skills, and talents would you
look for? Why?
Why is it important to create a positive working environment?
3. What types of professionals do you want to include in your success network?
What value can a professional provide?
What services would it make sense for you to delegate to a professional in your group’s
Opportunity Discovery Process? How can you connect with these individuals?
4. Describe the three phases of transformation. Why is it important to recognize the phase in which
you currently find yourself?
5. For each of the phases of transformation, what is the optimal mindset for success?
Will the mindset that created success in one phase of transformation also enable us to
succeed in another? Why or why not?
6. What did Dr. Land mean by saying “nothing fails like success”? How does this concept apply to an
entrepreneurial mindset?
Lesson 8 - The Power of Persistence
1. In what way(s) does being persistent in your personal life help you to create value for
others?
2. Sirena Moore says: “You have to get rid of all fear, and move forward no matter what… Be the best
you can be… Surround yourself with great people; learn how to network; learn how to meet the
people who have resources who can help you take yourself, your family, your business to the next
level.” (Show specific chalkboard segment).
Deconstruct and examine what Sirena is saying about persistence and an entrepreneurial
mindset in this passage.
How can you apply Sirena’s message to achieve your personal and/or professional goals?
3. Describe ways in which adversity can be an advantage. How can constraints and limited resources
be incentives? What knowledge can be gained from such circumstances?
4. As we have seen, Uncle Cleve was a man of average means who had no particular advantage over
anyone else in his small community. Yet, despite his circumstances and the limitations that were
beyond his control, he was able to prosper and thrive.
What was it that set him apart?
What were the specific beliefs and assumptions that empowered him to succeed?
How was he able to recognize opportunities where others could not?
How did he exercise his power to choose? What sacrifices did he make?
What can you accomplish by applying Uncle Cleve’s message to your own Opportunity
Discovery Process?
84
85
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
REFLECTION ASSIGNMENTS
Reflection prompts provide an opportunity to think about the future you want to create for yourself
and how best to apply the knowledge you have gained in a way that will enable you to accomplish
your goals.
Introduction Reflection: Describe the future you want to create. Before we can create the life we
imagine, we must first imagine the life we want to create.
Considering the follow questions:
1. What subjects, topics, or issues matter most to you? What does success look like to
you?
2. What are the most important things you want to make happen in your life and in your
career?
3. What are the greatest obstacles preventing you from accomplishing your goals?
4. How will you overcome these obstacles in order to accomplish your goals?
5. What do you want to get out this course?
Final Personal Vision Statement
For this final assignment, reflect on what you have learned from the Ice House Entrepreneurship
Program and how it may have altered or influenced your vision for the future you want to create.
Describe the journey you took throughout the course as well as a road map for how you will
accomplish your goals.
Consider responding to any or all of the following questions:
1. Now that you have completed this course, what is the future you envision for yourself?
2. How has your personal vision evolved since the beginning of the course?
3. What are the greatest obstacles that might prevent you from accomplishing your
goals?
4. How will you overcome these obstacles? What skills do you now need to learn?
5. What do you need to start doing? What do you need to stop doing?
6. What do you need to do more of? What do you need to do less of?
7. Which of the Ice House entrepreneurs inspired you most and why? What challenges did they
overcome? How do these challenges compare to your own? How has this entrepreneur affected
your mindset or personal vision?
8. Which of the Chalkboard lessons resonated with you most and why? How have these lessons
affected your mindset or personal vision?
9. Who is currently in your success network? What type of people do you still need to include in your
success network?
10. How do ordinary people, those with no particular advantage in life, manage to succeed regardless of
their circumstances?
Presentation Assignment
Assignment: Now that you are familiar with the Opportunity Discovery Process, it is time to convey
your ideas in a pitch-style presentation. This presentation will provide an opportunity to demonstrate
the evolution of your ideas and the Opportunity Discovery learning process while receiving any final
feedback from your peers.
For this presentation, we also suggest that you invite expert mentors, advisors, or other
entrepreneurs that you may have interacted with to attend. Facilitators may choose to invite several
expert mentors and entrepreneurs to participate on a panel to offer additional guidance and support.
Guidelines: Your presentation should be approximately 5-6 minutes long. Engage your audience
and be sure to demonstrate enthusiasm and professionalism while presenting. We recommend
using a PowerPoint presentation, the Opportunity Discovery Canvas, or other visual aids in your
presentation. However, visual aids should complement, not replace, face-to-face communication. An
additional 3-5 minutes should be set aside to respond to constructive feedback and questions from
your peers or expert mentors and advisors.
Directive: Using the entire canvas as a guide, clearly and concisely address the following
questions. Provide specific examples from your Opportunity Discovery Process:
86
87
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
1. What was your original idea?
2. How has your idea changed through your out-of-the-building customer interview
experience?
3. What else did you learn from other out-of-the-building knowledge sources?
4. Were you able to successfully validate a problem--solution fit with your idea? What evidence do
you have?
5. Will you proceed with your idea? If so, how will you expand your idea and connect with more
customers? If not, why not?
6. What are your next action steps beyond this course? What entrepreneurial or other business
opportunities will you pursue?
CHALKBOARD CHECKPOINTS
INTRODUCTION
1. Those who possess tacit knowledge are often unaware of the knowledge they possess or how it can
valuable to others. TRUE
For example, an experienced entrepreneur may not be able to describe how she was able
to successfully identify an opportunity. To her, it may seem as if it were a “sixth sense” -
something she just seems to have been born with rather than a logical thought process.
However, upon closer scrutiny and careful questioning, a thought process is often revealed.
2. A belief is the same as a fact. FALSE
A belief is something we may view as a fact yet it is important to understand that a belief is
not necessarily true. It is simply what we believe to be true. What is essential to understand
is that while some of our beliefs are based in fact, others may be inaccurate, out of date or
simply untrue? They may be things we have accepted as facts yet never really challenged or
tested for ourselves.
LESSON 1 - THE POWER TO CHOOSE
1. Our environment and the collective mindset of others have very little influence over the choices we
make. FALSE
The need to fit in often keeps us tethered to familiar ways of thinking and acting, limiting our
choices and keeping us tethered to a mindset that often keeps us stuck.
2. A reaction is often experienced as an impulse rather than a conscious choice. TRUE
A reaction is simply an unconscious choice. Reactions are often learned patterns of
thoughts, feelings, and actions. They are experienced as automatic or inevitable, as if they
were beyond our control. Without realizing it, when we react, we have unwittingly bypassed
our ability to make a conscious and deliberate choice.
3. Those with an external locus of control believe that luck, fate, circumstances or powerful others will
determine the outcome of their lives. TRUE
88
89
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
With an external locus of control we appear to have little or no say over the outcome of our
lives. From this perspective, it is others who enjoy all the power and prestige, leaving us
powerless to do anything about it.
4. By creating a vision we are exercising our power to choose. TRUE
Rather than reacting to our circumstances or following the crowd, a vision enables us to
focus our time and effort on a destination of our own choosing.
LESSON 2 - RECOGNIZING OPPORTUNITIES
Part 1
1. Coming up with a good idea is more important than your abilities as an entrepreneur
FALSE
While a good idea is important your abilities as an entrepreneur may be as important as the
idea itself.
2. Rather than in-depth planning, entrepreneurs often uncover larger more attractive opportunities
once they are in motion. TRUE
The process of interaction and observation, experimentation and adaptation is critical to an
entrepreneur’s ability to recognizing opportunities that others overlook.
Part 2
3. Inexperience can be an advantage that enables entrepreneurs to identify opportunities that
“experts” overlook. TRUE
Entrepreneurs like Bill Gates and Steve Jobs were able to recognize an opportunity that
“industry experts” in well-established companies had overlooked.
4. Entrepreneurs tend to be high stakes gamblers who are willing to bet everything on their ideas.
FALSE
While entrepreneurs do take risks, they tend to approach their endeavors as a series of
small, calculated risks rather than a big bold bet.
LESSON 3 - IDEAS INTO ACTION
Part 1
1. Most new businesses require bank financing or venture capital investors. FALSE
While some new ventures do require outside investment, the majority of new businesses are
started by entrepreneurs who initially pursue uncertain, niche opportunities that are unlikely
to attract outside investors or justify a traditional loan.
2. The term “proof of concept” refers to an entrepreneur’s ability to convince others that they have a
good idea. FALSE
Entrepreneurs approach their ideas as unproven assumptions rather than established facts.
They acknowledge the uncertainty and, rather than trying to prove their concept on paper,
they set out in search of hard evidence. In other words, they focus their time and resources
on finding customers who will actually buy their product or service. By finding customers they
begin to “prove” the viability of their concept.
3. Starting a business should only be attempted by those who are unemployed or not enrolled in
school. FALSE
Rather than quitting their job or abandoning their studies, many entrepreneurs start in their
spare time “bootstrapping” their way into business by finding creative ways to acquire new
knowledge, test their ideas and find customers - without quitting their jobs or dropping out of
school.
Part 2
4. Fear is an “internal barrier” that stops many would be entrepreneurs from acting on their ideas.
TRUE
For some reason, when it comes to taking action, so many of us seem to get stuck. We
seem to be trapped by an invisible barrier, a barrier that is difficult to identify - yet one that
can be overcome.
90
91
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
LESSON 4 - PURSUIT OF KNOWLEDGE
Part 1
1. 1. Knowledge alone is the engine that drives an entrepreneur. FALSE
Knowledge alone is not enough. Knowledge combined with effort creates a powerful
synergy that propels entrepreneurs beyond their circumstances and out into the world of
possibilities and untapped
2. Entrepreneurship often discourages participants from pursuing a formal education.
FALSE
While some new ventures do require outside investment, the majority of new businesses
are started by entrepreneurs who initially pursue uncertain, niche opportunities that are
unlikely to attract outside investors or justify a traditional loan.
3. Too much planning can blind us to unforeseen opportunities. TRUE
Often, through the process of face-to-face selling, entrepreneurs uncover unexpected
opportunities. For others, larger opportunities appear once their business is under way.
Part 2
4. Informal learning often becomes a lifelong process for an entrepreneur. TRUE
Entrepreneurship can redefine what it means to learn. Entrepreneurs like Uncle Cleve
understand the value of knowledge and they operate from an internal locus of control.
Their motivation to learn is intrinsic; they are motivated by the need for the knowledge itself,
rather than a diploma or a degree. And learning becomes a self-directed process. They do
not view learning as a one-time event nor do they allow themselves to be limited to learning
through traditional means.
LESSON 5 - CREATING WEALTH
Part 1
1. The appearance of wealth is usually a good indication of a persons true wealth. FALSE
Many of the people who appear wealthy - those who live in expensive homes and drive
luxury cars - do not actually have much wealth. They work hard to achieve success, yet they
often spend much of their discretionary income on things that create an outward appearance
of wealth. And by doing so, they often choke themselves with debt, undermining their ability
to create true wealth.
2. Discretionary income is the total amount of money a person earns. FALSE
Discretionary income is the amount of money a person has left overafter all monthly
expenses are paid.
3. The terms “spending” and “investing” are synonymous to an entrepreneur. FALSE
For the purposes of this course the term “spend” is defined as “to consume mindlessly or to
squander” while the term “invest” is defined as “to make use of our time, effort or money in
ways that are conducive to creating wealth”.
Part 2
4. Buying things on credit should be avoided at all costs. FALSE
For some, credit is a tool; a lever that enables us to increase our income and invest in things
that are conducive to creating wealth. Yet for others, the use of credit leads to a “buy now -
pay later” pattern of spending that often lures us into an endless cycle of working harder and
harder just to pay our debts - a kind of credit trap that leaves little room to invest our time and
resources into things that will enable us to create wealth.
92
93
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
LESSON 6 - BUILDING YOUR BRAND
Part 1
1. Defining our brand requires us to understand the problem we are solving from our customer’s
point of view. TRUE
As an entrepreneur, we are in the business of providing solutions. If we have not
accurately diagnosed the problem we are solving from the customer’s point of view, our
brand may be sending the wrong message about the product or service we provide. And
by doing so, we may be overlooking opportunities or sabotaging our own success.
Part 2
2. As an entrepreneur, there are two distinct means of communication: One is explicit, the other
implicit. TRUE
An explicit message is one that is clear and defined rather than implied. It is the literal
meaning of the words we say, either in print, on a website or through face-to-face
interaction. An implicit message on the other hand, is unspoken or implied rather than
clearly stated or expressed.
3. Confidence is something we either have or we don’t. FALSE
Confidence is a learned behavior, one that stems from our experience. Like Jason, as a
first-time entrepreneur, we may not have complete confidence in our abilities. We may
be operating outside of our comfort zone and we may not see ourselves as a successful
entrepreneur. Yet, as we discussed in lesson three, it is essential that we take the first
steps; it is essential that we act on our ideas.
LESSON 7 - CREATING COMMUNITY
Part 1
1. A social network is a social structure made up of people who are connected by common
interests or goals. TRUE
While the term has recently become popular, social networks have existed long before
the emergence of online social networks like LinkedIn, Facebook, and Twitter. In fact,
research has shown that social networks play a critical role in determining the way problems
are solved, organizations are run, and the way goals are achieved.
2. The most important members of our success community are mentors and advisers.
TRUE
Mentors and advisers are often the most effective members of our success network. Their
knowledge and experience can play an invaluable role. Just as large corporations have a
board of directors to oversee the direction of the company, we too should have a board of
mentors and advisers to provide guidance, accountability and support.
Part 2
3. The mindset and the skills that enable us to succeed in one phase of transformation will also enable
us to succeed in another. FALSE
The mindset and skills that enable us to succeed in one phase may not be effective in
another. The key, according to Dr. Land, is to understand and acknowledge each of the
three phases and to recognize which phase we are in and which set of skills should be
applied.
LESSON 8 - THE POWER OF PERSISTENCE
Part 1
1. Dawn’s mindset changed when she witnessed another severely disabled veteran who was
determined to succeed. TRUE
Thinking that she would never amount to anything, her mindset quickly changed when she
witnessed a severely disabled veteran who had lost both of his legs take his first steps.
2. Brian Scudamore’s business - 1 800-GOT JUNK - was an overnight sensation that was successful
from the start. FALSE
It took Brian 8 years to reach $1million dollars in sales. As Brian stated, his overnight
success has taken 22 years.
94
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
3. Ted and his daughter, Sirena, started their business when they received a six- figure contract.
FALSE
It was the awareness of a six-figure contract to clean a construction site that inspired them
to start their business. Their first job paid $400 for picking up debris for a roofing contractor.
4. Although he was raised as a foster child, Rodney Walker always knew that somehow he would
succeed. FALSE
Moving from one foster home to the next, Rodney saw life as a lottery that he could not win.
An entrepreneurship experience combined with the help of a mentor help shift his mindset
and his behavior began to change.
Part 2
5. Jason discovered that once he had the right formula, putting his plan into motion was easy.
FALSE
Knowing what to do was only half the battle for Jason. As he put it, “You can understand the
intellectual level - you can have a recipe - going out and executing on that is difficult.”
6. Palwasha was encouraged by others in her community to become an entrepreneur.
FALSE
As a young women growing up in Afghanistan, Palwasha was strongly discouraged from
becoming an entrepreneur. Yet, as she soon discovered, by refusing to give up, she could
alter her environment.
7. Ryan Blair attributed his success to being in the right place at the right time. FALSE
Ryan attributed his success to having a mentor as well as being teachable: “I was a poor
kid with poor beliefs - I became a rich kid because I got rich beliefs”.
8. David discovered that by solving problems for others he could create value for himself.
TRUE
After learning of a woman who was assaulted while using an ATM, he developed a solution
that would increase protection and security for ATM users.
96
97
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
RECOMMENDED SUPPLEMENTAL RESOURCES
In order to provide participants with a more enriching learning experience, facilitators may utilize
these recommended resources which are related to the field of entrepreneurship, entrepreneurial
skill-building, and the use of an entrepreneurial mindset. These materials are best used as
supplementary content to spark in-class discussions or to provide interested participants with more
learning material outside of class. However, these resources are NOT a mandatory component of
the Ice House Entrepreneurship program. For more supplemental resources please visit:
www.eli-group.com/resources
Books:
1. Quick and Nimble: Lessons from Leading CEOs on how to Create a Culture of Innovation
by Adam Bryant
2. The Origin and Evolution of New Businesses by Amar Bhide
3. The Person and the Situation: Perspectives of Social Psychology by Lee Ross & Richard E.
Nisbett
4. The Startup Owners Manual: The Step-by-Step Guide for Building a Great Company by Steve
Blank & Bob Dorf
5. The Entrepreneurial Imperative: How America’s Economic Miracle Will Reshape the World
by Carl J. Schramm
6. Mindset: The New Psychology of Success by Carol S. Dweck
7. The Founder’s Dilemmas: Anticipating and Avoiding the Pitfalls That Can Sink a Startup by Noam
Wasserman
8. Man’s Search For Meaning by Viktor E. Frankl
9. The Seven Habits of Highly Successful People: Powerful Lessons in Personal Change by Stephen
R. Covey
10. Outliers: The Story of Success by Malcolm Gladwell
11. Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything by Steven D. Levitt &
Stephen J. Dubner
12. Creating Innovators: The Making of Young People Who Will Change the World by Tony
Wagner
13. The Millionaire Next Door: The Surprising Secrets of America’s Wealthy by Thomas J. Stanley &
William D. Danko
14. Sources of Power: How People Make Decisions by Gary Klein
15. The Mismeasure of Man by Stephen Jay Gould
16. The Innovator’s Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail by Clayton
Christensen
17. The E Myth Revisited: Why Most Small Businesses Don’t Work and What to Do About It by Michael
E. Gerber
18. The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization by Peter M.
Senge
19. The Power of Positive Deviance: How Unlikely Innovators Solve the World’s Toughest Problems by
Richard Pascale, Jerry Sternin & Monique Sternin
20. The Power of Habit: Why We Do What We Do in Life and Business by Charles Duhigg
21. Grow or Die: The Unifying Principle of Transformation by George Land
Videos:
1. “Where Good Ideas Come From” by Steven Johnson
2. “Moving Windmills: The William Kamkwamba Story”
3. The “Entrepreneurial Mindset” Kauffman Sketchbook
4. “Changing Education Paradigms” RSA Animate
98
99
Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved Copyright 2015 Entrepreneurial Learning Initiative, LLC All Rights Reserved
TED talks:
1. Start with Why” by Simon Sinek
2. “How Will You Measure Your Life?” by Clay Christensen
3. “The New Era of Positive Psychology” by Martin Seligman
Blogs:
1. Mr. Money Mustache blog
2. Edutopia financial literacy resources blog
3. Farnam Street Blog
4. Steve Blank’s Entrepreneurship and Conversation
5. Marketing:
“Great Ideas for Teaching Marketing” (online)
“Growth Hackers” (online)
6. Market analysis:
a. “Segmentation Study Guide” (online)
7. Pitching/presentations:
Entrepreneur.com’s “6 steps to a perfect pitch”
Harvard Business Review’s “How to pitch a brilliant idea”:
“How to Pitch Your Idea” on Graphics.com, taken from Scott Berkun’s “Myths of Innovation”
VinaMaria’s “How to Effectively Present Your Ideas” on Slideshare.net
Microsoft’s “Tips for Presenting Powerpoints by Microsoft Office”
Michael Hyatt’s “5 Rules for More Effective Presentations”
Nancy Duarte’s “The Secret Structure of Great Talks”
8. Effective essay writing tools:
The Purdue Online Writing Lab (OWL)
9. Harvard Business Review’s “Storytelling That Moves People”
Useful websites:
1. entrepreneur.com
2. eonetwork.org