Age UK factsheet 20 July 2024
NHS Continuing Healthcare and NHS-funded nursing care Page 6 of 36
3.3 How is NHS CHC eligibility decided?
An NHS CHC eligibility decision is based on your day-to-day needs. It
rests on deciding whether the main aspects, or the majority part, of the
care you need is focused on addressing and/or preventing health needs.
If it does, it means you have a ‘primary health need’.
Having a particular diagnosis does not determine eligibility - people with
the same health condition can have very different needs. There is no
requirement for specialist staff to be providing care. However, staff
contributing to your assessment must have relevant skills, knowledge
about and an understanding of your underlying condition(s).
The term ‘primary health need’ is from a 1999 Court of Appeal case
known as Coughlan Judgment. The judge found there was a limit on
nursing care assistance an LA could legally provide when, taken as a
whole, nursing or other health services you require are:
⚫
no more than incidental or ancillary to the provision of the care and, if
required, accommodation which an LA is, or would be but for your means
(income/capital), under a duty to provide (the ‘quantity test’), and
⚫
not of a nature beyond which an LA, whose primary responsibility is to
provide social services, could be expected to provide (the ‘quality test’).
When considering NHS CHC eligibility, staff look at key characteristics
of your needs in 12 areas in the DST, and their impact on the care you
require. This is to help determine whether the care you require exceeds
the limits of a local authority’s responsibilities. The 12 areas are listed in
section 5.3.
The key characteristics are:
Nature - the type and features of your needs - physical, psychological or
mental - and type of support or treatment needed to manage them.
Intensity - relates to the severity of your needs, how frequently and to
what extent they vary, and the resulting level of support required.
Complexity - how different needs present and interact with each other to
increase the knowledge and skills staff need to a) monitor symptoms
b) treat any multiple conditions; and how this affects management of
your care. Staff also look at your response to your condition and how it
affects your overall physical and mental health.
Unpredictability – how much, how often and how unexpectedly
changes in your condition create challenges because of the timeliness
and skills required to manage needs that arise. It can affect the level of
monitoring required to ensure you and others are safe and the level of
risk to you or others, unless you receive adequate, timely care.
Each of the characteristics may on their own, or in combination,
demonstrate a ‘primary health need’ because the quantity, the quality, or
a combination of the quantity and quality of care required to meet your
needs, exceeds the limits of an LA’s responsibilities.