Latham & Watkins June 5, 2023 | Number 3117 | Page 2
restricts the individual from engaging in any of the following activities after the termination of their
employment (or, presumably, engagement, in the case of an independent contractor):
•
working for another employer for a specified period of time;
•
working in a specified geographical area; or
•
working for another employer in a capacity that is similar to the employee’s (or independent
contractor’s) work for the employer that is party to the non-compete.
However, the law makes clear that a non-compete does not include: (i) a nondisclosure agreement,
(ii) an agreement designed to protect trade secrets or confidential information, (iii) a non-solicitation
agreement, or (iv) an agreement restricting the ability to use client or contact lists or solicit customers of
the employer. These exceptions do create a few questions, including what the term “non-solicitation
agreement” means (e.g., employee non-solicitation, customer non-solicitation, etc.) and where the line is
drawn between a permissible non-solicitation provision and an unlawful non-competition provision.
2. The law applies to agreements with employees and certain independent contractors
The law applies to non-competes between an employer and an employee, but broadly defines the term
“employee” to be “any individual who performs services for an employer, including independent
contractors.” The law defines an “independent contractor” as an individual whose engagement is
governed by a contract and whose pay is not reported on a Form W-2, and specifically includes any
entity that an individual formed for purposes of entering into a contract for services, when the employer
required such entity formation as a condition of receiving compensation under an independent
contractor agreement. As used throughout this Client Alert, the term “independent contractor” has this
meaning.
3. The law bans all non-competes with employees and independent contractors, with
two exceptions
Under the law, any non-compete with an employee or independent contractor is void and unenforceable,
except for non-competes that are agreed upon:
•
during the sale of a business; or
•
in anticipation of the dissolution of a partnership, limited liability company, or corporation.
More specifically, when there is a sale of a business, the buyer and “the person selling the business and
the partners, members, or shareholders” may agree on a non-compete that prohibits the “seller” of the
business from carrying on a similar business in a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable
length of time. However, the level/type of interest that one must hold in the business to be considered a
“seller” is unclear under the law. For example, the law does not address whether a “seller” would include
individuals who dispose of only a small interest in the business, or who are option holders or other
holders of derivative securities.
When the dissolution of a business is anticipated, the partners, members, or shareholders may agree
that any or all of them will not carry on a similar business in a reasonable geographic area where the
business has been transacted.
The law does not provide guidance as to what would be a reasonable geographic scope or length of time
for a permissible non-compete.